Mathematics and Uncertainty in Architectural Design Decision-Making

Mathematics and Uncertainty in Architectural Design Decision-Making

Alireza Parvizi1 Sepideh Nasresfahani2

1) 1. Faculty of Architectural engineering, Sepehr Danesh Moaser Institute of Higher Education, Isfahan, Iran. e-mail address:
2) 2. Department of Pure Mathematics, Faculty of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran. e-mail address:

IOI Code : ABEB-ACZFFF
Publication : 4th International Conference on Recent Advances in Engineering, Innovation and Technology - Belgium(eitconf.com)
Abstract :
    In contemporary architecture, the relationship between mathematics and architecture has expanded with the development of modeling and computation, from the description of geometric and quantitative relationships to the analysis and evaluation of more complex design processes. However, architectural design takes place under conditions in which incomplete information, variability in parameters, uncertain future conditions, and changing goals and preferences can affect design decisions. This study asks what role mathematical frameworks for dealing with such uncertainty can play in the analysis and decision-making of architectural design, and what the limits of this role are in addressing uncertainties within the design process. The study adopts an analytical–conceptual literature review, examining design literature, mathematical frameworks for uncertainty, and studies related to building performance assessment and decision-making in relation to one another. The findings indicate that uncertainty in design is not a uniform condition and may concern data, parameters, models, future conditions, or decision-makers’ preferences and values. Accordingly, probability, statistics, sensitivity analysis, decision theory, and scenario-based and robust decision-making approaches provide different capacities for formulating, inferring, and analyzing the consequences of uncertainty. The architectural examples reviewed further show that responding to changing conditions, using computation, or introducing adaptive capabilities does not in itself constitute formal uncertainty analysis. Rather, uncertainty must be explicitly defined in the problem, incorporated into the model, and its effects on consequences or decisions must be analyzed. The limits of this approach become apparent in model assumptions, the quality and context-dependence of data, preferences and values, and changes in the design problem itself. Mathematics can therefore support the formulation and analysis of part of the uncertainty and reveal its implications for design decisions, while architectural judgment and choice remain beyond the output of the mathematical model.

Keywords : mathematics architecture uncertainty sensitivity analysis building performance simulation design decision making