Fraud and Abuse of Letters of Credit in the Chinese Legal System
Fraud and Abuse of Letters of Credit in the Chinese Legal System
Mohsen Haghi1 Zahra Fazeli2 Maryam Shiari3 Rosa Salar4 Aysan Barzegari Sadaghiani5 Atiyeh Safari6 Seyed Ali Sajedi Amin7
1) M.A. in Commercial Companies Law, University of Judicial Sciences and Administrative Services, Tehran, Iran; Judicial Trainee
2) M.A. in Criminal Law and Criminology, Islamic Azad University, Birjand, Iran
3) M.A. in Private Law, Attorney at Law
4) B.A. in Law, Islamic Azad University, Nowshahr, Iran; Attorney at Law
5) M.A. in Financial-Economic Law, Islamic Azad University, Salmas, Iran
6) M.A. in Oil and Gas Law, University of Tehran, Iran
7) M.A. in Criminal Law and Criminology, Mofid University, Qom, Iran
IOI Code
:
ABKH-ACZZGB
Publication :
4th International Conference on Applied Researches in Humanities, Economics, Management & Accounting(icrhema.com)
Abstract :
The letter of credit is one of the most important payment instruments in international trade, the effectiveness of which is based on two fundamental principles: the independence of the credit from the underlying transaction and the necessity of strict compliance with the terms of the documents. Nevertheless, the reliance of the letter of credit on the appearance of the documents, in some cases, provides grounds for abuse and fraud and raises the necessity of recognizing an exception to the principle of independence. The present research, using a descriptive-analytical method and a comparative approach, has examined the concept and instances of fraud in letters of credit and the manner in which the legal and judicial systems of Iran and China confront this phenomenon. The findings of the research show that in Chinese law, the regulations of the Supreme People s Court on the handling of letter of credit disputes, approved in 2005, have created a relatively clear framework for identifying fraud and have considered forgery or insertion of incorrect information in documents, failure to deliver goods or delivery of worthless goods with bad faith, and collusion to present documents in the absence of a real underlying transaction as among its most important instances. Chinese judicial practice has also, in cases related to forgery of bills of lading, fictitious transactions, and repeated collateral, attempted to establish a balance between preserving the validity of the principle of independence and preventing fraudulent exploitation of the letter of credit. In Iranian law, although UCP 600 recognizes the principle of independence of the credit, the fraud exception has not been explicitly and comprehensively provided for in these regulations, and its recognition is mainly based on general legal principles, good faith, and judicial practice. Examination of the judgment of the Supreme Court in judgment number 9209982161800835 also shows that in the event of establishing bad faith, collusion, and fundamental non-conformity of the goods with the subject of the transaction, the principle of independence can be limited. The conclusion is that China s experience can provide a suitable model for Iranian law in the field of legislating clear criteria for fraud, determining the conditions for issuing a stop-payment order, distinguishing fraud from mere breach of contract, and strengthening banking supervision mechanisms and digitization of documents; provided that the independence of the credit and the security of commercial exchanges continue to be preserved as the main rule.
Keywords : letter of credit fraud exception principle of independence chinese law good faith