Analysis of Progressive Collapse due to Sudden Column Removal under Impact in Reinforced Concrete Intermediate Moment Frames using a Brittle Fracture Model

Analysis of Progressive Collapse due to Sudden Column Removal under Impact in Reinforced Concrete Intermediate Moment Frames using a Brittle Fracture Model

hassan ebrahimi1 babak jafarzad eslami2

1) Master s student Email:
2) Assistant Professor, Ghiyasuddin Jamshid Kashani University, Abike

IOI Code : AACZ-ABHCZB
Publication : The 5th International Conference on Seismic Retrofitting(5icst.ir)
Abstract :
    Progressive collapse following sudden events can lead to either partial or total structural damage. The inability of adjacent members to redistribute the additional loads induced by the removal of a structural element results in a chain-like propagation of failure in both vertical and horizontal directions, ultimately leading to local or global collapse of the structure. The existence of alternative load paths for transferring the additional loads caused by member removal is of critical importance. Therefore, one of the commonly adopted code-based approaches in progressive collapse analysis is the alternate load path method.In this study, the mechanism of progressive collapse in reinforced concrete moment-resisting frames is investigated using the alternate load path analysis method, along with the formation of catenary action to transfer the additional loads generated by the removal of a key structural member. By examining the vertical displacement at the location of the removed member under different removal scenarios, as well as the rotation of beam ends adjacent to the damaged member, it was observed that the potential for progressive collapse in frames depends on the location of the removed column or member. The collapse potential due to corner column removal is significant in both upper and lower stories and results in larger displacements. Moreover, when a column or key member is removed in higher stories, the magnitude of displacement increases due to the availability of fewer alternative load paths; in other words, fewer members participate in absorbing the kinetic energy generated by the sudden loss of the element. The presence of structural irregularities leads to non-uniform force distribution in the remaining members and more severe structural responses under key member removal scenarios.Progressive collapse refers to situations where initial local damage leads to disproportionate collapse that is not commensurate with the initial triggering event. Although abnormal loads are not typically considered in conventional design, their occurrence may result in partial or total collapse of structures. Over the past decades, numerous cases of global or local structural failures have been observed due to abnormal loads such as fire, impact, and explosion.In this study, the cracking behavior and nonlinear response of concrete structures under loading are investigated numerically using the Brittle Cracking model. The main objective is to evaluate the influence of key material parameters and modeling conditions on crack initiation and propagation patterns, load-carrying capacity, and overall structural behavior.In the adopted model, concrete behaves linearly elastic until reaching its tensile strength, after which cracking initiates in regions subjected to high tensile stresses. As cracks propagate, stiffness degradation occurs in the damaged regions, resulting in nonlinear structural behavior. In this regard, parameters such as tensile strength, elastic modulus, shear retention factor, material density, and mesh size are considered as influential factors in the analysis.The results indicate that increasing tensile strength and elastic modulus delays crack initiation, enhances load-bearing capacity, and reduces deformations. Furthermore, an increase in the shear retention factor improves stress transfer across cracked regions and enhances post-cracking stability of the structure.

Keywords : abaqus progressive collapse shear retention factor finite element method