Reviewing the role of project portfolio management in organizational value-based decision-making

Reviewing the role of project portfolio management in organizational value-based decision-making

Amin kamaei1 Mehran Derakhshandeh2 Varahram Ahmadzadeh3

1) Project portfolio supervisor of sahare-babak copper complex, National Iranian Copper Industries Engineering and Development Company,
2) Senior enterprise PMO specialist, National Copper Industries Engineering and Development Company of Iran,
3) Senior technical and economic studies specialist , National Iranian Copper Industries Engineering and Development Company,

IOI Code : AAGF-AAKKDK
Publication : 9th International Conference on Applied Researches in Science & Engineering (carseconf.com/9th)
Abstract :
    In many project-oriented organizations, decision-making remains predominantly driven by financial indicators and cost-control considerations. However, at the strategic level, it is strategic value—rather than merely achieving lower costs or on-time delivery—that defines the organization’s future trajectory. Excessive reliance on a cost-centric perspective often results in project selection and prioritization processes that are reactive, short-sighted, and misaligned with long-term objectives. Consequently, organizational capacity is consumed by activities that generate limited value and contribute minimally to the creation of sustainable competitive advantage. By revisiting the distinctions among project management as a process focused on output delivery, program management centered on benefit creation and realization, and portfolio management whose primary aim is value maximization, this article demonstrates how shifting from an execution-oriented view to a value-driven perspective clarifies the boundary between “doing things right” and “doing the right things.” Recent developments in the international literature indicate that modern decision-making approaches—such as real-time data analytics, dynamic multi-criteria models, and scenario planning for volatile conditions—are increasingly employed in project value assessment, and that traditional metrics of cost, time, and quality alone are insufficient to represent a project’s true value. Accordingly, the article proposes a three-layer framework for evaluating and weighting project portfolios in industrial organizations. First, the degree of strategic alignment between projects and the organization’s overarching vision and benefits is examined. Next, the sustainability and depth of value creation across the benefit lifecycle are assessed. Finally, risks, uncertainties, and the available execution capacity required for value realization are evaluated. This integrated approach enables managers to make more accurate investment decisions, improve the balance between short-term and long-term projects, and enhance the organization’s strategic agility in today’s turbulent and highly competitive environments.

Keywords : project portfolio management (ppm) organizational value orientation strategic alignment multi criteria decision making (mcdm) program and project management project value assessment multi criteria weighting