Comparative Study of the Fraud Exception to the Independence Principle in Letters of Credit

Comparative Study of the Fraud Exception to the Independence Principle in Letters of Credit

Mohsen Haghi1 Sara Sepahbod Bakhshayesh2 Mahshid Bahrami3 Zahra Fazeli4 Reza Lotfalinejad5 Nastaran Masaebi6 Sina Shayan Asl7

1) Master of Commercial Company Law, University of Judicial Sciences and Administrative Services, Tehran, and Judicial
2) Master of Communication Law, Allameh Tabataba i University, Tehran, and Attorney at
3) Master of Family Law and Attorney at Law
4) Master of Criminal Law and Criminology, Islamic Azad University, Birjand Branch
5) Bachelor of Law, Ershad University of Damavand
6) Bachelor of Law, Payame Noor University, Qidar
7) Master of International Commercial Law, Islamic Azad University, North Tehran Branch

IOI Code : AAGK-ABAGFG
Publication : 4th International Conference on Researches in Accounting, Economics, Management & Humanities(meaconf.com/4th)
Abstract :
    The Letter of Credit (L/C) relies on the Independence Principle, separating bank obligations from the underlying contract ; however, absolute adherence to this principle can facilitate commercial fraud. This study employs a comparative approach to examine fraud as the primary exception to this principle within Iranian, English, American, and Chinese law. The findings reveal a contrast between the narrow approach (limited to document forgery) and the broad approach (extending fraud to the underlying transaction) across different legal systems. The article concludes that the Iranian legal system, based on general principles such as the prevention of unjust enrichment, has the capacity to adopt the broad approach to prevent the violation of rights, provided that the fraud is clearly established

Keywords : letter of credit independence principle fraud exception underlying transaction comparative law