Comprehensive Analysis of the Factors Influencing the Performance Variability of Nano-Engineered Concretes: A Systematic Review of the Roles of Nanomaterial Characteristics, Dispersion, Agglomeration, and Compatibility with the Cementitious Matrix
Comprehensive Analysis of the Factors Influencing the Performance Variability of Nano-Engineered Concretes: A Systematic Review of the Roles of Nanomaterial Characteristics, Dispersion, Agglomeration, and Compatibility with the Cementitious Matrix
Masoud Abbaszadeh Ghavifekr1
1) Department of Civil Engineering,Technical and Vocational University (TVU), Tehran, Iran
IOI Code
:
AAHD-ABKZBF
Publication :
National Conference on Information Technology, Nanotechnology, Artificial Intelligence and Technological Futures Studies(itnaf.ir)
Abstract :
Nanotechnology has attracted widespread attention in recent years as an innovative approach for modifying the structure and enhancing the performance of cementitious materials. The use of nanosilica, carbon nanotubes, graphene oxide, nano-calcium carbonate, and nano-TiO₂ can improve the performance of cementitious materials through microstructural modification, acceleration or alteration of hydration processes, and enhancement of physical and mechanical properties [1,4]. However, the results reported in different studies regarding the magnitude and even the direction of the effects of nanomaterials sometimes exhibit considerable discrepancies. This variability cannot be attributed solely to the type and dosage of the nanomaterial; rather, the intrinsic characteristics of the nanomaterial, the method and quality of dispersion, the degree of agglomeration, physical–chemical compatibility with the cementitious environment, matrix composition, and curing conditions simultaneously influence the final performance [5,8].
The present study aims to systematically analyze the factors influencing the performance variability of nano-engineered concretes. Accordingly, 24 selected studies on nanosilica, carbon nanotubes, graphene oxide, nano-CaCO₃, nano-TiO₂, and hybrid systems were reviewed. Data related to the type of nanomaterial, its key characteristics, dispersion methods, the use of ultrasonication and surfactants, agglomeration state, compatibility with the cementitious matrix, and final performance indicators were extracted and comparatively analyzed.
The results showed that adequate dispersion of a nanomaterial in the initial suspension does not necessarily ensure the preservation of stable dispersion within the cementitious matrix [1,9,10]. Furthermore, the alkaline environment and the presence of calcium ions may cause suspension instability and reagglomeration of certain nanomaterials [13,14]. The analysis of the selected studies demonstrated that the performance variability of nano-engineered concretes results from the multifactorial interaction among nanomaterial characteristics, dispersion quality, agglomeration state, compatibility with the cementitious matrix, and testing and curing conditions. Accordingly, the following conceptual framework was proposed to explain the final performance:
[
P=f(N,D,A,M,T)
]
where (P) represents the final performance of nano-engineered concrete, (N) denotes the intrinsic characteristics of the nanomaterial, (D) represents dispersion quality, (A) indicates the agglomeration state, (M) denotes the degree of compatibility between the nanomaterial and the cementitious matrix, and (T) represents the testing and curing conditions. This framework demonstrates that the performance evaluation of nanomaterials in concrete should move beyond the simple approach of considering only the “type and dosage of nanomaterial” and instead focus on the simultaneous analysis of nanomaterial characteristics, dispersion processes, stability within the cementitious environment, and testing conditions.