Cross-Cultural Validation of an AI Integration Framework in Architectural Education: A Comparative Study Across the United States, Europe, and the Middle East

Cross-Cultural Validation of an AI Integration Framework in Architectural Education: A Comparative Study Across the United States, Europe, and the Middle East

Kamran Javaheri1 Fatemeh Bazan2

1) Department of architecture, Se.c, Islamic Azad University, Semnan, Iran,
2) Department of architecture, Se.c, Islamic Azad University, Semnan, Iran,

IOI Code : AAHF-ABFEAB
Publication : National Conference on Architecture and Art Technologies, Smart City, Soft and Creative Industries and Technological Culture(icact.ir)
Abstract :
    Objective: This study aims to design and validate a cross-cultural framework for measuring artificial intelligence integration in architectural curricula across three regions: the United States, Europe, and the Middle East. Methodology: The present research employs a mixed-methods approach (qualitative-dominant) using a three-phase design including a systematic literature review (Systematic Review 2025), a cross-cultural Delphi technique with the participation of 24 experts (eight from each region), and a field test in six architectural programs (two from each region). Data were analyzed using directed content analysis, thematic analysis, and framework analysis. Findings: Five main components of AI integration in architectural education were identified: algorithmic literacy, transparency and interpretability, machine autonomy, depth of adaptive feedback, and alignment with design learning objectives. These five components are valid across all three regions; however, their operational definitions and qualitative weights differ significantly based on cultural context. In the United States, machine autonomy and algorithmic literacy play the most prominent roles. In Europe, transparency and interpretability are the primary priorities. In the Middle East, adaptive feedback and alignment with design learning objectives, alongside the preservation of the instructor s central role as a human mediator, hold the greatest importance. The proposed final framework, comprising shared indicators, region-specific indicators, and a local calibration mechanism, was successfully tested in all three regions. Conclusion: Cultural homogenization in the design of educational AI assessment tools is the primary factor leading to their failure. The framework presented in this study is the first operational and tested model for measuring AI integration in architectural education that embeds local calibration capacity as an integral part of its core structure. This framework can serve as a foundation for designing training courses, revising curricula, and informing policy-making at both national and international levels.

Keywords : cross cultural validation artificial intelligence integration architectural education united states europe middle east