Final Examinations and the Use of Evaluation Results in Educational Systems: A Comparative Systematic Review and Presentation of the TARA Conceptual Framework

Final Examinations and the Use of Evaluation Results in Educational Systems: A Comparative Systematic Review and Presentation of the TARA Conceptual Framework

Abbasi1 Aghajani2

1) AliPh.D. Candidate Department of Educational Studies and Curriculum Planning, Islamic Azad University, Arak, Iran
2) Bachelor s Degree Graduate in Educational Sciences, Payame Noor University, Shazand Center, Shazand, Iran.

IOI Code : ABDE-ABKGAE
Publication : 6th International Conference on Advanced Research in Management And Humanities(huconf.com)
Abstract :
    Final examinations are among the most common assessment tools in educational systems; however, their value largely depends on how the results are interpreted and utilized. This article aimed to examine the analysis and application of final examination results and to compare the existing approaches in selected educational systems. The present study is a systematic review conducted in accordance with the PRISMA 2020 guidelines. Studies and reports published between January 2015 and March 2026 were searched in selected scientific databases and the official websites of OECD and UNESCO, and were screened based on inclusion and exclusion criteria. After screening and quality assessment, 47 documents—including 39 articles and 8 official reports—were selected for final analysis. Data were analyzed using a thematic analysis approach and organized into four domains: curriculum, teaching methods, assessment, and educational management. The review findings indicated that differences among educational systems are not merely about the presence or absence of final examinations, but rather about how the results are interpreted and used, the role of teachers in the assessment process, and the extent to which test data are linked to educational decisions. In Finland, basic education assessment relies mainly on teacher-centered evaluation and continuous feedback. In Singapore, assessment data are used alongside educational guidance mechanisms and curricular leveling. In Quebec, the considerable weight of certain final examinations has raised debates about test pressure and the role of summative assessment. In Iran, particularly at the elementary level, the use of performance-based evidence alongside teacher-centered evaluation is emphasized, although challenges remain in the systematic analysis and coherent use of educational data. Based on the review findings, the effective use of test results requires linking assessment data, educational feedback, and decision-making at both the school and system levels. Finally, a conceptual framework is proposed to organize the process of analysis, feedback, action, and review in the use of test results; however, its validity and effectiveness still require empirical testing.

Keywords : final examinations educational assessment systematic review comparative analysis educational data analysis educational feedback