Photography Without a Camera: The Redistribution of Agency in AI-Driven Advertising Photography

Photography Without a Camera: The Redistribution of Agency in AI-Driven Advertising Photography

Saideh HajAliArab1 Zahra Golnaz Montaghi Fasaei2

1) M.A. Graduate in Photography, Faculty of Art, Islamic Azad University, Central Tehran Branch, Tehran, Iran
2) Assistant Professor, Department of Dramatic Arts, Faculty of Art, Islamic Azad University, Central Tehran Branch, Tehran, Iran

IOI Code : ABEB-ACAFEC
Publication : 4th International Conference on Recent Advances in Engineering, Innovation and Technology - Belgium(eitconf.com)
Abstract :
    With the emergence of deep learning architectures and generative networks, advertising photography has shifted from an optical process of recording reality to a paradigm of computational image production. This technological transformation has transferred the locus of decision-making from the human agent to autonomous systems and has thrown the concept of agency into crisis. The present study aims to analyze the redistribution of agency within the AI-driven advertising image generation pipeline and to redefine the professional role of the photographer. The research method is qualitative and exploratory in nature, with data collected through semi-structured interviews with nine advertising specialists, participatory observation of the algorithmic process, and a visual discrimination test based on a pair of equivalent images (one produced by traditional capture and one generated by artificial intelligence) evaluated by three expert reviewers. The findings reveal that agency has been rebalanced from physical execution and technical control toward semantic management and command engineering. The results of the visual discrimination test indicate the reviewers’ inability to distinguish a computational output from an optical capture on the basis of purely visual elements; discrimination became possible only by reliance on metadata, the complex behavior of light reflection in multi-layered environments, and imperfections such as text distortions within the image. This underscores the necessity of a shift from the concept of “indexicality” toward “processual transparency.” Finally, the study introduces the “three-layer model of agency redistribution,” according to which the photographer’s role is elevated from a mere instrumental producer to an “architect of perception” — a role responsible for the strategic management of meaning, curatorial selection, and ethical oversight of algorithmic biases within a human–machine co-creative structure.

Keywords : advertising photography generative artificial intelligence agency redistribution architect of perception processual transparency