A review of methods for determining and estimating the Bond Work Index in ball and rod mills: from the standard Bond method to rapid, kinetic, and ore-property-based methods

A review of methods for determining and estimating the Bond Work Index in ball and rod mills: from the standard Bond method to rapid, kinetic, and ore-property-based methods

sina soleimani1 mahmod eskandari nasab2

1) M.Sc. Student in Mineral Processing Engineering, Shahid Bahonar University of Kerman
2) Ph.D. in Mineral Processing Engineering, Shahid Bahonar University of Kerman

IOI Code : ABEB-ACZGGB
Publication : 4th International Conference on Recent Advances in Engineering, Innovation and Technology - Belgium(eitconf.com)
Abstract :
    The Bond Work Index (Wi) is one of the most important and widely used engineering parameters in mineral processing, quantifying the resistance of ore to comminution and serving as the basis for the design and selection of comminution equipment (crushers, rod mills, and ball mills) at industrial scale. Despite its widespread application, the Bond Standard Method has always been subject to criticism due to its lengthy procedure (typically seven to ten grinding cycles), the need for a large sample (about ten kilograms), and the absence of a precise international standard such as ISO or ASTM, which has driven the development of alternative and faster methods. In this review paper, drawing on five principal studies, the theoretical foundations and procedure of the Bond standard method are first described; then the rapid method based on first-order grinding kinetics, the approach of analyzing the variability of the Bond Work Index and the introduction of the Maxson Index, the Cumulative Kinetic Model (CKM) and its relationship with Bond parameters, a comprehensive review of more than fifteen alternative methods for determining the Bond Work Index, and finally the effect of mineralogical texture and mechanical properties of rock on the Bond Work Index value in a gold mine are examined. The results show that rapid methods can, with an error typically less than 10% compared to the standard method, reduce testing time from about eight hours to less than two hours and sample requirement by about seventy percent, while the correlation between the grindability parameter gpr (or G) and product particle size is more stable and reliable than the direct correlation of the Bond Work Index with particle size.

Keywords : bond work index bond ball mill grindability comminution kinetics comminution grinding energy consumption