A Comparative Geometric–Structural Analysis of Steep, Standard, and Shallow Panj-o-Haft Arches in Brick Barrel Vaults Based on Zomorshidi’s Drawing Method and Limit Analysis of the Thrust Line
A Comparative Geometric–Structural Analysis of Steep, Standard, and Shallow Panj-o-Haft Arches in Brick Barrel Vaults Based on Zomorshidi’s Drawing Method and Limit Analysis of the Thrust Line
Muhammad Shahriyari1 Hamed Heydari Sureshjani2
1) Researcher in Geometry and Architecture; Ph.D. Candidate in Architecture at Shahid Rajaee Teacher Training University, Tehran, Iran.
2) M.Sc. in Architectural Engineering; Grade 1 Member of the Construction Engineering Organization; Architecture Instructor.
IOI Code
:
ABFG-ACACCK
Publication :
12th.international Congress on Civil Engineering, Architecture, Art and Urban Development(12icsau.ir)
Abstract :
Three Panj-o-Haft arches (steep, standard, and shallow), constructed using Zomorshidi’s drawing method, are comparatively investigated in brick barrel vaults with spans of 2.5, 5, and 7.5 m and arch thicknesses of 20 and 40 cm. The arch, infill up to a flat roof, and the two supporting load-bearing walls beneath it are examined through an integrated limit analysis based on linear programming. The effects of pseudo-static seismic loading, lateral pressure and passive resistance of the infill, snow, rain, repeated spans, and inclined buttresses are evaluated.nnThe proposed method is validated against published numerical and experimental results, showing deviations of 0.2% and 6% from numerical reference values, respectively, while the experimental results are 26–41% lower than the theoretical predictions.nnAn arch thickness of 40 cm is geometrically stable across all three spans, whereas a thickness of 20 cm is adequate only for the 2.5 m span. The required wall thickness for a wall height of h = 3 m is approximately 0.9–2.0 m. The seismic collapse multiplier of the 40 cm arches ranges from 0.01g to 0.75g, with the shallow arch exhibiting the best seismic performance. Repeated spans reduce the thickness of the internal wall to 0.8 m but do not improve the external wall or seismic resistance. The passive resistance of the infill increases seismic capacity by up to approximately 90%.nnThe findings constitute a limit-theory-based preliminary assessment and do not replace experimental testing or three-dimensional nonlinear analysis.
Keywords : panj o haft arch zomorshidi barrel vault brick on edge masonry thrust line limit analysis geometric safety factor infill catenary iranian architecture