Presenting New Methods for Seismic Retrofitting of Masonry Buildings Using Tuned Mass Dampers and Buckling Braces with a Cost Reduction Approach

Presenting New Methods for Seismic Retrofitting of Masonry Buildings Using Tuned Mass Dampers and Buckling Braces with a Cost Reduction Approach

Ehsan Rezazadeh Kermani1

1) Master of Science in Civil Engineering - Construction Management, Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch, Iran

IOI Code : ABKD-ABKKGA
Publication : Fourth International Conference on applied researches in civil engineering, architecture and urban planning (icarcau.com)
Abstract :
    Existing masonry buildings, especially those without proper bracing, rigid diaphragms, and reliable connections between perpendicular walls, are susceptible to shear cracking, out-of-plane failure, mortar joint slip, and progressive collapse during moderate and severe earthquakes. Conventional retrofit methods such as global shotcrete, reinforced concrete jackets, or reinforcing grids, although they can increase capacity and integrity, are often associated with increased weight, downtime, destruction of architectural coatings, and significant implementation costs. The aim of this study is to develop a low-cost framework for seismic retrofitting of low-rise masonry buildings using two response control technologies, namely tuned mass damper (TMD) and buckling brace (BRB), and to investigate the possibility of their selective combination. The study began with a systematic review of recent studies from 2023 to 2026, and then a three-story masonry building was analyzed as a multi-degree-of-freedom shear model. To avoid attributing artificial data to the real experiment, seismic inputs were generated as a set of reproducible band-limited synthetic signals at three PGA levels of 0.15, 0.30, and 0.45g. Five scenarios were investigated, including the existing building, TMD, BRB, full hybrid system, and low-cost selective hybrid system. The results of the parametric study showed that at the 0.30g level, TMD alone reduced the average maximum drift by about 22.9%; BRB reduced this index by about 44.8% and full hybrid by about 50.6%. The selective hybrid design with TMD with a mass ratio of 3% and BRB limited to critical floors provided a more favorable balance between performance, architectural intervention, and cost, with about 43.9% reduction in drift and lower normalized initial cost than the full hybrid. Multi-criteria decision analysis shows that phased retrofitting, focusing BRB on floors with higher shear demand, and using existing roof masses as part of TMD can reduce the cost and time of building closure. The main conclusion of the study is that for short-rise masonry buildings, the “demand control + selective strengthening” strategy can be an economical alternative to global strengthening, provided that the connections, diaphragms, and out-of-plane mechanisms are modified before installing seismic control equipment.

Keywords : masonry building seismic retrofitting tuned mass damper tmd buckling brace brb