Completing the identity framework of mathematical research in PhD
Completing the identity framework of mathematical research in PhD
Mohammadesmail Nikfar1
1) Associate Professor, Ph.D. in Mathematics, Department of Mathematics, School of Hekmat 1, District 4, Tehran, Iran.
IOI Code
:
ADFK-ACAEFA
Publication :
The 2nd International Conference on Modern Education in Social Sciences and Sociology of Iran(https://www.ktconf.ir/2nd)
Abstract :
For the purposes of this article, "mathematics" is used as a broad term encompassing the mathematical sciences. Although the "mathematical community" consists of all individuals recognized as mathematicians, the terms "mathematical community" and "mathematicians" are employed throughout the paper to denote a specific collection of mathematicians—a usage clarified by the explicit adoption of a particular definition of what constitutes a "mathematician." While a mere collection of mathematicians is not synonymous with a "community," this approach allows us to examine how different definitions of a "mathematician" shape the composition of the resulting community—effectively drawing a boundary between those included and those excluded. This article explicitly explores and interrogates the assumptions and ideologies associated with the term "mathematician." To this end, three primary themes are presented, offering a framework based on three distinct ways of defining a "mathematician"—grounded in identity, practice, and competence. Drawing upon the lived experiences of the co-authors, this framework complements existing literature on mathematical identity. The second theme focuses on analyzing the definitions, underlying assumptions, and implications of the term "mathematician." The third theme addresses the concept of identity as a mathematician, exploring the significance and consequences of various definitions within the context of self-reflection and critical inquiry. The objective is not to establish a single, "correct" definition, but rather to provide a framework for researchers working with data from the mathematical community—enabling them to clarify their definitions and the rationale behind their chosen criteria for the specific subject matter they are investigating.
Keywords : higher education mathematician doctoral research doctoral education and studies supervisor