Empowering the Independence Approach in Mathematics Doctoral Research
Empowering the Independence Approach in Mathematics Doctoral Research
Mohammadesmail Nikfar1
1) Associate Professor, Ph.D. in Mathematics, Department of Mathematics, School of Hekmat 1, District 4, Tehran, Iran.
IOI Code
:
ADKD-ACAEBK
Publication :
The Fourth International Conference on Innovative Research in Education and Schools with a Horizon of Progress and Development, Hamedan.(https://edu.iseconf.ir/4th)
Abstract :
Reflections from students highlight the consequences of taking risks, revealing shifts in their self-perception as well as their attitudes toward mathematics and writing. They noted a significant transformation in their thinking. Previously, not viewing themselves as "mathematicians," they felt their ideas lacked importance and that others in the class did not truly value their contributions. However, this assumption proved to be mistaken; when errors arise—such as during the development of a mathematical proof—sharing ideas within groups helps reveal both shared and distinct thought processes. Recognizing that peers value their own work—and that one can, in turn, value the work of others—helps individuals broaden their own horizons. Consequently, one student noted that they are now more comfortable accepting this reality and are more willing to try again. Another student realized that all ideas—whether correct or incorrect—are valuable and significant, as they are integral to the learning process. They learned that mathematics is not merely about arriving at the "correct" answer; rather, it requires perseverance to establish meaningful connections. Although this individual initially sought to become more comfortable with writing in the context of mathematics, the subject itself provided them with valuable insights. They came to understand that "not knowing" has its own value, and as the course progressed, they became increasingly willing to take risks in both their writing and their thinking. Drawing on research regarding "growth mindset," it is argued that approaches to teaching mathematics should be reconsidered. He has created opportunities for forging new connections, helping students bridge the gap between how mathematics is actually learned and how it is traditionally taught. Like all proponents of a "growth mindset," he believes that mistakes serve as valuable, productive opportunities for growth. Consequently, placing excessive emphasis on the final product—whether in mathematics or essay writing—deprives students of the chance to grow; instead, it merely rewards them for repeating what they have always done. It is argued that focusing on the process—and allowing students (and even instructors) to make mistakes and reflect upon them—is one of the most significant strengths of this approach. Further information, along with the sources and references consulted, is provided.
Keywords : higher education constructive struggle and failure doctoral research active growth mindset inquiry based learning