Investigating the Impact of the Legal and Regulatory Environment on Audit Quality and Auditor Independence in Iran

Investigating the Impact of the Legal and Regulatory Environment on Audit Quality and Auditor Independence in Iran

Mehdi Rasaei1

1) PhD Student in Accounting, Islamic Azad University, Damavand Branch, Tehran Province, Iran.

IOI Code : AADH-AAFCFD
Publication : The second international conference on new researches in management, law, humanities and entrepreneurship(icmlhe.ir/2nd)
Abstract :
    The legal and regulatory environment plays a decisive role in shaping both the quality of audit practices and the independence of auditors, especially in transitional economies such as Iran. This study investigates how Iran’s evolving legal and regulatory frameworks influence audit quality and auditor independence, two pillars that underpin the credibility and transparency of financial reporting. Employing a qualitative research methodology, the study draws on semi-structured interviews with audit professionals, regulators, and academic experts, complemented by a detailed analysis of Iranian legislation and standards, including the regulations of the Iranian Association of Certified Public Accountants (IACPA) and the Securities and Exchange Organization (SEO). Findings illustrate a dynamic landscape: Regulatory reforms in recent years, such as the introduction of audit committee disclosure requirements and enhanced oversight by the SEO, have improved transparency and imposed stricter expectations on audit conduct. However, the study reveals persistent challenges, including ambiguities in statutory definitions of auditor independence, inconsistencies in enforcement, and limited legal protection for whistleblowers. Such gaps often lead to situations where auditors face pressures from clients or management, undermining their objectivity and, consequently, audit quality. Notably, smaller audit firms experience greater vulnerabilities due to their dependence on concentrated client portfolios and resource limitations, making them particularly susceptible to both overt and subtle threats to independence. Moreover, the absence of comprehensive whistleblower protection discourages auditors from reporting unethical practices, while infrequent and lenient enforcement of regulations reduces overall deterrence. Conversely, large and internationally affiliated audit firms tend to demonstrate higher compliance levels, partly owing to better training, access to global best practices, and internal quality assurance mechanisms. The study also identifies opportunities within the current legal framework, including ongoing efforts towards harmonization with international standards and judicial reforms aimed at strengthening professional accountability. Based on these insights, the paper recommends clarifying legal definitions, bolstering enforcement capacities, enacting robust whistleblower protections, and investing in continuous professional development as actionable steps to enhance audit quality and independence in Iran. These measures are essential for fostering investor confidence, promoting corporate accountability, and ensuring sustainable economic growth.

Keywords : audit quality auditor independence legal environment regulatory framework iran