Robust Decision Thresholds for Concrete Wharf Repair Under Cost and Closure Uncertainty
Robust Decision Thresholds for Concrete Wharf Repair Under Cost and Closure Uncertainty
Arman Aminzadeh Vahedi1 Majid Safehian (Corresponding Author)2 Alireza Rasekhi Sahneh3 Mohsen Jafari Nadoushan4
1) PhD Candidate, Department of Civil Engineering (Construction Engineering and Management), SR.C., Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran. Email:
2) Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, SR.C., Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran. Email:
3) Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, QE.C., Islamic Azad University, Qeshm, Iran. Email:
4) Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, CE.C., Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran. Email:
IOI Code
:
ABEB-ACAGZC
Publication :
4th International Conference on Recent Advances in Engineering, Innovation and Technology - Belgium(eitconf.com)
Abstract :
Repair-method decisions for concrete wharves depend on construction cost and berth-closure duration, yet small input errors can invalidate a nominally dominant option. This paper develops an independent, reproducible bounded-uncertainty analysis using eight documented repair alternatives from a Bushehr Port engineering case. Technical eligibility is treated as a mandatory prerequisite rather than a score to trade against cost. We derive an exact pairwise robustness threshold for Pareto dominance under symmetric relative uncertainty, evaluate two explicitly hypothetical candidate sets, test illustrative budget and closure limits, and quantify preference reversals in weighted comparisons. Based on cost and closure alone, the dominance of method M5 over M4 is guaranteed up to 9.09% common uncertainty; the corresponding limits are 24.41% for M6 over M7 and 45.45% for M8 over M7. When a previously reported but uncalibrated GWI indicator is provisionally added, the thresholds become 2.15%, 24.41% and 21.63%, respectively. Under illustrative caps of 100 million IRR/m and three closure months, M6 and M8 are nominally feasible, but only M6 remains feasible with a 10% worst-case allowance. For an illustrative M6/M8 comparison, the preferred option changes when the cost weight reaches approximately 45.43% using cost and closure, or 46.11% with the provisional third index. The results demonstrate how audit-ready decision margins can be calculated without inventing additional observations or claiming that technically different repairs are interchangeable. This study provides a standalone uncertainty-screening contribution; site application requires verified prices, repair eligibility and environmental inventory.
Keywords : wharf repair robust dominance uncertainty berth closure decision support