Beyond the Cartesian Divide: A Genealogy of Architectural Autonomy Toward Hybrid Ontologies

Beyond the Cartesian Divide: A Genealogy of Architectural Autonomy Toward Hybrid Ontologies

Shervin Mirshahzadeh1 Alireza Ajayebi2

1) Islamic Azad University, Central Tehran Branch
2) Islamic Azad University, Central Tehran Branch.

IOI Code : ABGG-ABHKKH
Publication : 11th.International Conference on Researches in Science & Engineering & 8th.International Congress on Civil, Architecture and Urbanism in Asia(11icrsie.ir)
Abstract :
    Architectural autonomy has long oscillated between two dominant poles: the conception of architecture as a self-legislating formal discipline and its dissolution into relational, social, ecological, or technological networks. This article argues that both positions remain constrained by a residual Cartesian logic that separates object from world, form from milieu, and subject from matter, even when such dualisms are ostensibly challenged. In response, the paper develops a genealogical and comparative account of architectural autonomy across three paradigmatic regimes: disciplinary formalism, relational assemblage, and object-oriented autonomy. Through a morpho-ontological matrix that examines the ontological status of the architectural object, the positional logic of the subject, and the spatial morphology of built form, the article analyzes three emblematic cases: Le Corbusier’s Unité d’Habitation, SANAA’s Rolex Learning Center, and selected projects/discourses associated with Mark Foster Gage. The argument advanced is that autonomy should neither be defended as absolute formal isolation nor abandoned in favor of total relational immanence. Instead, it must be reformulated as a relative and stratified condition operating within hybrid ontologies, where architecture emerges through unstable negotiations among objects, bodies, material systems, environmental forces, and representational orders. Within this framework, the article introduces ontological grafting as an operative concept that describes the productive disturbance generated when heterogeneous ontological regimes are joined without being reconciled into unity. Rather than resolving contradiction, grafting preserves tension as a design and theoretical resource. The article contributes to contemporary architectural theory by offering a post-dualist model of autonomy that is capable of accounting for formal specificity while remaining responsive to more-than-human, material, and relational realities.

Keywords : architectural autonomy hybrid ontologies object oriented ontology relational architecture ontological grafting posthuman architectural theory