The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on Redefining the Foundations of Criminal Liability and Emerging Challenges for the Criminal Justice System in the Face of Advanced Technologies

The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on Redefining the Foundations of Criminal Liability and Emerging Challenges for the Criminal Justice System in the Face of Advanced Technologies

Arina Abdollahi1

1) Master of Criminal Law and Criminology, Islamic Azad University, Sanandaj Branch, Sanandaj, Iran

IOI Code : ABGG-ABKFKG
Publication : 11th.International Conference on Researches in Science & Engineering & 8th.International Congress on Civil, Architecture and Urbanism in Asia(11icrsie.ir)
Abstract :
    The accelerated integration of artificial intelligence into policing, prosecution, and adjudication has transformed decision-making in the justice system, exposing a fundamental mismatch between human-centered criminal law and algorithmic processes. As machine learning tools are increasingly deployed for evidence analysis, recidivism risk scoring, and predictive policing, traditional criminal law doctrines regarding voluntary action, causation, and subjective intent are severely strained. This paper examines how artificial intelligence redefines the foundations of criminal liability and identifies the emerging systemic challenges confronting the modern criminal justice system. Employing a doctrinal and comparative literature-review methodology, this study analyzes contemporary academic debates, legislative frameworks, and case law concerning autonomous systems, liability attribution models, and constitutional rights. The findings indicate that AI-induced harms are rarely the result of isolated human actions, but rather emerge from complex, distributed socio-technical networks, rendering traditional individualistic liability models inadequate. While models like the innocent agency doctrine fail to account for true algorithmic autonomy, shifting toward systemic corporate negligence and strict product liability offers a more viable path to address accountability gaps. Furthermore, the findings reveal that the opacity of “black box” algorithms directly undermines procedural due process and the right to a fair trial by preventing defendants from inspecting or challenging algorithmic evidence. Simultaneously, the reliance on biased historical data in risk assessments and predictive policing perpetuates systemic discrimination, converting statistical correlations into preemptive assumptions of guilt. In conclusion, this paper argues that the criminal justice system must transition from reactive regulation to proactive governance. To preserve the rule of law and protect fundamental human rights, jurisdictions must establish harmonized, international standards for algorithmic auditability, enforce strict transparency mandates that override corporate trade secrets, and implement robust “human-in-the-loop” protocols to safeguard the presumption of innocence in the digital age.

Keywords : artificial intelligence criminal liability mens rea algorithmic transparency predictive policing