Patterns of Regional Planning Systems Worldwide: A Comparative Review of Selected Countries Experiences
Patterns of Regional Planning Systems Worldwide: A Comparative Review of Selected Countries Experiences
somayeh ahani1 Paniz Barzegar2 Nazanin Mirzabeigi3
1) Assistant Professor, Faculty of Urban Planning, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran
2) MSc Student in Planning, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
3) MSc Student in Planning, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
IOI Code
:
ACDK-ACZFGK
Publication :
4th International Conference Civil Engineering, Architecture and Urban Planning(4cau.ir)
Abstract :
Regional planning systems around the world have been shaped by each country s governance structure and legal traditions, and classical typologies in this field have largely focused on the experience of European countries. This study undertakes a comparative examination of regional planning systems in five countries — France, Germany, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, and Japan — selected to capture a spectrum of governance patterns and continental diversity. Using a comparative review method and four axes of comparison (institutional, implementation, legal, and financial), the findings show that the diversity of these systems cannot be reduced to the binary spectrum of centralized versus decentralized, but must instead be sought in the combination of three dimensions: institutional-legal structure, operational-financial arrangements, and the way the regional scale is bounded. On this basis, three general patterns were identified: unitary systems inclined toward gradual reform (France, Japan), negotiation-based systems with institutional division of authority (Germany, the Netherlands), and an asymmetric, selective system (the United Kingdom). The findings of this study — particularly regarding cross-scale coordination that extends beyond formal administrative boundaries, and the relationship between institutional and financial autonomy of regions — can offer lessons for reconsidering Iran s regional planning system.
Keywords : regional planning comparative study territorial governance decentralization spatial planning systems