Legal Challenges of Blockchain-Based Smart Contracts and Solutions for Resolving Their Disputes
Legal Challenges of Blockchain-Based Smart Contracts and Solutions for Resolving Their Disputes
Mahshid Keshavarz1
1) Bachelor of Law, Shiraz Branch, Islamic Azad University, Shiraz, Iran.
IOI Code
:
AABF-AAGEEA
Publication :
3rd International Conference on Applied Researches in Humanities, Economics, Management & Accounting(icrhema.com/3rd)
Abstract :
Blockchain-based smart contracts, as one of the fundamental innovations in the last decade, have been able to transform the traditional concept of a contract. These contracts are executed in the form of computer code on a decentralized network platform and have features such as transparency, encrypted security, elimination of intermediaries, and automatic execution. Despite these advantages, the technical and non-transparent nature for the public, along with the cross-border and immutable nature of the blockchain platform, have brought serious legal and enforcement challenges; including the difficulty of identifying and authenticating the parties, determining jurisdiction and governing law, legal citation, low interpretation and flexibility, conflict with privacy requirements, and ambiguity in assigning responsibility in cases of code errors or unintended execution. This research was conducted with the aim of identifying and comprehensively analyzing the legal challenges of smart contracts and providing effective solutions to resolve disputes arising from them. The research method was developed analytically and comparatively, using library resources, international documents, scientific articles, and a review of the practical practice of different legal systems (written law, common law, and supranational). The research findings show that traditional dispute resolution mechanisms face serious limitations due to the self-executing and unstoppable nature of smart contracts. Although modern blockchain-based mechanisms, such as arbitration and on-chain voting (such as Kleros and Aragon Court), are fast and transparent, they face shortcomings in terms of compliance with national laws and handling complex disputes. The combination of traditional and technological approaches (Hybrid Dispute Resolution) was introduced as an efficient model that can implement the decision of the selected judicial or arbitration authorities in a smart contract by using oracles. Based on the results, the legal framework proposed in this study includes a set of key principles (transparency, dual interpretation of code and text, determination of governing law, data protection, and allocation of liability) and recommends the establishment of voluntary or semi-governmental registration and monitoring institutions. Harmonization of this framework with international standards (UNCITRAL, ICC, ISO) can increase the cross-border acceptance and legal security of these contracts. Finally, the present study concludes that the sustainable development of smart contracts requires a combination of legal and technical perspectives, specialized training of reviewers, and updating of existing laws. The implementation of the proposed framework can provide a reliable and efficient platform for the widespread use and international legitimacy of this new tool.
Keywords : smart contract blockchain dispute resolution legal framework arbitration