The majority is not always right; weakening of the opinion of the primitive expert in the shadow of expert panels; a threat to judicial justice

The majority is not always right; weakening of the opinion of the primitive expert in the shadow of expert panels; a threat to judicial justice

Hossein Yousefi1

1) Official expert in the field of roads and construction

IOI Code : AACA-ABBKHB
Publication : 10th.International Conference on Researches in Science & Engineering & 7th.International Congress on Civil, Architecture and Urbanism in Asia(10icrsie.com)
Abstract :
    The opinion of an official judicial expert constitutes a fundamental instrument for fact-finding in judicial proceedings. However, in Iranian judicial practice, an implicit yet influential tendency has emerged to prioritize the opinions of expert panels merely based on the numerical majority of their members over the initial expert’s opinion. This approach lacks legal, logical, and scientific foundations and, in certain cases, leads to the erosion of expert independence, disregard for well-reasoned technical analyses, and facilitation of organized corruption. Adopting an analytical and critical approach grounded in the principles of fair trial, this article examines the legal status of expert opinions within the Iranian judicial system and critiques the fallacy of “numerical majoritarianism” in evaluating expert evidence. The study demonstrates that a higher number of experts does not necessarily ensure greater accuracy or truthfulness and may, under specific circumstances, contribute to deviation from factual reality. Finally, the article proposes practical, institutional, and legislative reforms to improve judicial and disciplinary practices and safeguard the professional independence of impartial experts.

Keywords : official judicial expert expert panel numerical majority expert independence fair trial judicial justice