Applying alternative and complementary cultural punishments in preventing crimes in the field of cultural heritage

Applying alternative and complementary cultural punishments in preventing crimes in the field of cultural heritage

Samineh Nikpour1 Hosein Esmaili Sangari2

1) Master s student in Restoration of Historical Buildings and Textures, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Planning, Tabriz Islamic Art University
2) Assistant Professor and Faculty Member of the Cultural Heritage Research Institute

IOI Code : AAGH-AAHAHF
Publication : Architectural Heritage at Risk (Challenges of War, Natural Disasters, and Mismanagement in the Islamic World) (icahr.ir)
Abstract :
    In recent years, violations related to cultural heritage, including unauthorized excavation, destruction of historical monuments, and smuggling of antiquities, have become a worrying trend. In addition to material damage, these crimes inflict irreparable damage on the country s historical and cultural identity. This research seeks to answer the question of what effect a punishment of knowledge and culture can have on a criminal in the field of cultural heritage? In other words, have coercive punishments such as imprisonment and fines, etc. had an effect on the non-repetition of crimes in the field of cultural heritage? The purpose of this research is to provide a solution to reduce crimes related to cultural heritage by using complementary punishments to prison and refers to restorative justice, in which, instead of imposing heavy punishments (such as prison or fines), the court requires the criminal to read a book, write an article, or perform cultural and educational work in the field of cultural heritage, relevant and proportionate to his crime. The research method was qualitative and the data were collected through field and library studies such as reports obtained from the legal department of the General Department of Cultural Heritage, Tourism and Handicrafts of East Azerbaijan Province, interviews with legal and cultural experts, and analysis of real examples of sentences issued in Iran. The research findings indicate that more than fifty percent of criminals in this field, within a short period of time after their release, resort to committing the same crime again and as a result are returned to prison repeatedly. Therefore, the use of restorative approaches from the restorative justice subcategory, in which cultural awareness and interaction are prioritized, can lead to the correction of the offender s attitude and the promotion of his social responsibility while reducing the costs of the judicial system. Therefore, the success of this approach requires the development of specific executive regulations, training of judges, and close cooperation with cultural institutions.

Keywords : cultural heritage traditional punishment alternative punishment restorative punishment recidivism