Comparative Analysis of Integration and Autonomy Levels in Helix, Holonic, and Spotify Models: Implications for Human Resource Management in Iranian Knowledge-Based Companies
Comparative Analysis of Integration and Autonomy Levels in Helix, Holonic, and Spotify Models: Implications for Human Resource Management in Iranian Knowledge-Based Companies
Sina Mohammadi1
1) PhD in Public Administration, Human Resource Management Orientation Islamic Azad University, Tehran Central Branch Email:
IOI Code
:
AAGK-ABCCHK
Publication :
4th International Conference on Researches in Accounting, Economics, Management & Humanities(meaconf.com/4th)
Abstract :
Objective: This research aims to conduct a comparative analysis of integration and autonomy levels in three modern organizational design models (Helix, Holonic, and Spotify) and examine their implications for human resource management in Iranian knowledge-based companies.
Method: The study employed a qualitative approach with a multiple case study strategy. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews with 24 human resource managers, CEOs, and organizational consultants from 8 knowledge-based companies located in Tehran Science and Technology Park. The data were analyzed using thematic analysis with MAXQDA 2020 software.
Findings: The findings indicate that the Helix model has the highest level of integration at 63.7%, manifested in HR mechanisms such as dual career ladders and internal talent marketplace. The Spotify model demonstrates the highest level of autonomy at 58.8%, reflected in self-managing teams, 360-degree feedback systems, and self-directed learning platforms. The Holonic model falls in the middle of this spectrum at 54.2%, characterized by dynamic roles and nested self-organizing structures. The main challenges of implementing these models in Iran include: weakness in HR maturity (85% frequency), hierarchical organizational culture (79% frequency), and middle managers resistance to delegating authority (72% frequency).
Conclusion: A hybrid Helix-Spotify model is proposed as a localized framework for Iranian organizations, enabling a dynamic balance between integration and autonomy. This model can serve as a foundation for designing flexible human resource systems in knowledge-based companies.
Keywords : organizational design helix model holonic model spotify model organizational integration autonomy knowledge based companies