Comparative Analysis of the Legislative Criminal Policy of Iran and France in the Criminalization of Environmental Harm and the Determination of Criminal Sanctions, with a Focus on the Status of Ecocide as a Crime against Humanity in the Statute of the International Criminal Court

Comparative Analysis of the Legislative Criminal Policy of Iran and France in the Criminalization of Environmental Harm and the Determination of Criminal Sanctions, with a Focus on the Status of Ecocide as a Crime against Humanity in the Statute of the International Criminal Court

Fardin Rezaei1

1) M.A. in Criminal Law and Criminology, Islamic Azad University, Sanandaj Branch, Sanandaj, Iran.

IOI Code : AAHA-ABFZFK
Publication : 5th.International Congress on Management, Economy, Humanities, Education and Business Development(5icmba.ir)
Abstract :
    Global developments in environmental criminal law have highlighted the necessity of revising and aligning national criminal policies with international standards. The environment, as the foundation of human life, has faced extensive threats in recent decades, leading legal systems to increasingly criminalize environmentally destructive behaviors. Within this framework, Iran and France present two distinct models of legislative criminal policy toward environmental protection, and a comparative analysis of these models can clarify the strengths and weaknesses of each system. The main objective of this study is to comparatively analyze the legislative structure and criminal sanctions of Iran and France regarding the criminal protection of the environment and to examine their compatibility with the international concept of Ecocide as a crime against humanity. The research adopts a descriptive–analytical approach with a comparative method. Legislative data, legal documents, and scholarly sources from both countries were examined and analyzed based on indicators such as legislative structure, sanctions, and their connection to international law. The findings indicate that Iran’s criminal policy in environmental criminalization is fragmented, reactive, and lacking institutional coherence, whereas France’s criminal policy has developed based on a preventive, systematic approach aligned with the principles governing international law. Through the adoption of the Environmental Code, effective monitoring mechanisms, and proportionate restorative and criminal sanctions, France has established a deterrent system compatible with international standards. In contrast, Iran still requires substantial reforms in this field. The conclusion of the study suggests that, in order to align with global developments—particularly regarding the recognition of Ecocide in international criminal law—Iran needs to move toward adopting a comprehensive environmental law, strengthening effective sanctions, recognizing the criminal liability of legal persons, and reinforcing restorative mechanisms to establish an efficient, justice-oriented system compatible with global standards.

Keywords : legislative criminal policy environment criminalization ecocide international criminal law