Assessing the Effectiveness of Electronic Evidence in Crime Detection and Criminal Prosecution with Emphasis on Challenges of Admissibility, Authentication, and Privacy Protection in Iranian Criminal Law
Assessing the Effectiveness of Electronic Evidence in Crime Detection and Criminal Prosecution with Emphasis on Challenges of Admissibility, Authentication, and Privacy Protection in Iranian Criminal Law
Niloufar Mahmoudnasab1
1) M.A. in Criminal Law and Criminology, Islamic Azad University, Sanandaj Branch, Sanandaj, Iran
IOI Code
:
AAHA-ABFZGZ
Publication :
5th.International Congress on Management, Economy, Humanities, Education and Business Development(5icmba.ir)
Abstract :
The expansion of information and communication technologies in recent decades has led to a significant portion of human interactions taking place in digital environments, resulting in the production and storage of vast amounts of electronic data. These developments have confronted legal systems with a new phenomenon known as electronic evidence, which today plays a crucial role in many criminal cases in the processes of crime detection and prosecution. In Iran’s criminal justice system, with the increase in cyber-related crimes and the presence of digital traces in many traditional offenses, the use of electronic evidence has gained growing importance. However, the distinctive nature of this type of evidence—such as its intangible character, the possibility of data manipulation, and its dependence on technical tools and expertise—has created challenges regarding its admissibility, evaluation, and authentication in criminal proceedings. The primary objective of this research is to assess the effectiveness of electronic evidence in the processes of crime detection and criminal prosecution within Iranian criminal law, and to examine the major challenges related to admissibility, authentication, and privacy protection in the use of such evidence. This study adopts a descriptive–analytical method and is based on library research. Relevant legal provisions, doctrinal perspectives, and findings of previous studies have been examined and analyzed to provide a relatively comprehensive picture of the status and function of electronic evidence in Iran’s criminal justice system. The findings indicate that electronic evidence has significant capacity for identifying offenders, reconstructing the sequence of criminal events, and uncovering criminal networks, and can play an effective role in discovering the truth alongside other forms of evidence. However, challenges such as difficulties in verifying data authenticity, the potential for digital manipulation, lack of sufficient technical expertise among some judicial actors, and the absence of comprehensive standards for collecting and analyzing such evidence limit its full effectiveness. Moreover, the tension between the necessity of crime detection and the protection of citizens’ privacy is considered one of the most important issues in the use of electronic evidence.
Keywords : electronic evidence iranian criminal law crime detection evidence authentication privacy protection