From Deputy to CEO: A Conceptual Framework for Explaining Leadership Succession Failure in Organizations

From Deputy to CEO: A Conceptual Framework for Explaining Leadership Succession Failure in Organizations

Sasan Mehranpour1

1) PhD Student in Management, Department of Management, Sanandaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Sanandaj, Iran.

IOI Code : AAHA-ABHZGG
Publication : 5th.International Congress on Management, Economy, Humanities, Education and Business Development(5icmba.ir)
Abstract :
    In hierarchical structures of organizations, a phenomenon is frequently observed: individuals who perform brilliantly in the role of the second-in-command (deputy, senior advisor, or Chief Operating Officer), after being promoted to the first-in-command position (CEO or head of the organization), experience a significant decline in effectiveness. This research, employing the method of conceptual framework development and theoretical analysis, first reviews the existing literature in the fields of organizational behavior and leadership science, demonstrating that previous theories - including the Peter Principle, the COO Trap, and the distinction between leadership emergence and leadership effectiveness - have each independently failed to provide a comprehensive explanation of this phenomenon. By proposing the conceptual framework of the Complementarity Paradox as a theoretical model for explaining succession failure, this article argues that the psychological and behavioral characteristics that make an individual an exceptional second-in-command - including loyalty to another s vision, focus on executional details, and courage in decision-making under the protective umbrella of the first-in-command - when overused in the first-in-command position, are likely to transform into barriers to effectiveness. Therefore, promoting a second-in-command to the first-in-command position is not a skill leap, but rather an identity revolution in which many individuals fail. This article employs empirical evidence from the fields of football (Carlos Queiroz) and business (Steve Ballmer) to explain this paradox, and ultimately presents a conceptual model, testable hypotheses, and practical recommendations for organizational succession planning systems.

Keywords : second in command succession planning succession failure leadership effectiveness complementarity paradox identity transition role transition