Critique and Examination of the Principles of Civil Responsibility in Iranian and European Law

Critique and Examination of the Principles of Civil Responsibility in Iranian and European Law

Zainab Khub Vishkai1

1) Professional Scholar, Law Group, Fomin Unit, Payam Noor University, Fomin, Iran .Email:

IOI Code : AAHA-ABKAAC
Publication : 5th.International Congress on Management, Economy, Humanities, Education and Business Development(5icmba.ir)
Abstract :
    Civil liability, as one of the most important institutions of private law, plays a fundamental role in compensating for damages and establishing justice between individuals. This article aims to criticize and examine the principles governing civil liability in Iranian law and the legal systems of European countries, and analyzes the theoretical foundations and pillars of this legal institution. The main question of the research is to what extent the foundations and principles of civil liability in Iranian law are in line with the developments and new approaches in European law and what shortcomings and capacities exist in this field. The research method in this article is descriptive-analytical and based on a comparative study of legal sources. The research findings show that in Iranian law, despite the implicit acceptance of new theories, the main emphasis is still based on fault, while in many European legal systems, especially in recent decades, a significant trend towards accepting liability without fault and the theory of risk is observed. Also, in European law, the rules of compensation for damages are applied more flexibly and more effective protection is provided for the injured party, while in Iranian law, limitations in proving fault and causality sometimes prevent the full realization of compensatory justice. Finally, the article, by presenting a critical analysis, while explaining the strengths and weaknesses of both systems, emphasizes the need to review some of the principles and rules of civil liability in Iranian law and offers suggestions for convergence with more efficient approaches.

Keywords : civil liability fault theory of risk compensation for damages iranian law european law liability without fault