Transitioning from Testimony-Centered Approaches to Relying on Welfare Records in Proving Insolvency: An Analysis of Iranian Judicial Practice
Transitioning from Testimony-Centered Approaches to Relying on Welfare Records in Proving Insolvency: An Analysis of Iranian Judicial Practice
Mahdi Eslampanah1
1) M.A. Student in Private Law, Department of Law, Natanz Branch, Islamic Azad University, Natanz, Iran -
IOI Code
:
AAHA-ACZZFZ
Publication :
5th.International Congress on Management, Economy, Humanities, Education and Business Development(5icmba.ir)
Abstract :
The institution of insolvency is envisioned in the civil procedure system as a fundamental mechanism to guarantee the right to litigation and equal access to justice. However, the prevalence of the traditional testimony-centered approach in courts—due to its narrative and episodic nature, as well as witnesses lack of insight into complex modern asset structures—has created widespread practical challenges, such as the prevalence of fraudulent testimonies and the infringement of creditors rights. Meanwhile, the state possesses system-wide insight into household economic conditions through the Iranian National Welfare Information Database. Employing a descriptive-analytical methodology, this study re-evaluates the status of traditional evidence and explores the feasibility of invoking welfare records in insolvency determination proceedings. Findings indicate that while official welfare data do not constitute conclusive legal presumptions, they hold the status of an enhanced judicial presumption and admissible official electronic records. Accordingly, this paper proposes a hybrid bundle of evidence model. In this framework, online welfare records serve as the initial benchmark for assessing financial capacity, evaluated alongside bank inquiries, registry reports, and witness statements within the adversarial principle; a model that mitigates the initial burden of proof while establishing an optimal balance between supporting genuinely insolvent debtors and safeguarding creditors rights.
Keywords : insolvency witness testimony welfare records judicial presumption iranian welfare information database burden of proof