Knowledge Structure and Conceptual Clusters in the Fourth Generation of Public Policy Implementation: A Bibliometric Analysis of Scopus Data

Knowledge Structure and Conceptual Clusters in the Fourth Generation of Public Policy Implementation: A Bibliometric Analysis of Scopus Data

Seyed Aref Elahi1

1) Ph.D. Candidate in Public Administration (Decision-Making and Public Policy), University of Tehran, Iran –

IOI Code : AAHC-ABCKCD
Publication : National Conference on Management, Commercialization, Knowledge-Based Economy and Investment for Production(impeb.ir)
Abstract :
    Research Problem: Studies of public policy implementation have undergone significant conceptual shifts in the past decade, a process that some scholars refer to as the “fourth generation of policy implementation.” This study aims to map the conceptual landscape of this emerging domain and to identify its collaboration patterns and research trends. Methodology: Using the Scopus database, scientific documents related to “policy implementation” that included fourth-generation concepts (such as governance networks, collaborative governance, complex adaptive systems, co-creation, and others) were extracted for the period 2010–2025 (695 English-language articles). Bibliometric analysis was conducted using VOSviewer (version 1.6.20). The parameters included keyword co-occurrence (minimum of five occurrences), country co-authorship networks, citation analysis (highly cited references), and overlay visualization to display temporal research trends. After preprocessing (harmonizing synonymous keywords), the data were imported into VOSviewer, and thematic clusters and collaboration networks were generated. Key Findings: Keyword clustering revealed five major conceptual clusters representing distinct subdomains within fourth-generation policy implementation studies. These clusters encompass themes such as street-level bureaucracy, multi-level and networked governance, collaborative and adaptive environmental governance, evidence-based policy and public health, as well as policy learning and policy transfer. Country co-authorship analysis revealed an extensive global scientific collaboration network in which leading countries (the United Kingdom, the United States, Germany, the Netherlands, and China) occupy central positions, forming two major collaboration blocs (European and Anglo-Saxon/Asian). Citation analysis indicated that classical works—such as Street-Level Bureaucracy (Lipsky, 1980) and foundational frameworks of collaborative governance (e.g., Ansell & Gash, 2008)—are consistently cited as core references in this domain. Temporal analysis demonstrated that themes such as policy capacity and policy instruments have gained attention in recent years, whereas earlier concepts such as federalism and complex adaptive systems were more prominent in the early 2010s. Innovation and Contribution: This study provides, for the first time, a comprehensive depiction of the knowledge structure within the fourth generation of policy implementation research. The findings offer valuable insights for policy scholars seeking to identify research gaps and for policymakers aiming to understand actor networks and emerging thematic hotspots for planning future research agendas. Moreover, the application of bibliometric methods and the VOSviewer tool in this study can serve as a methodological model for similar scientometric analyses in policy-related fields.

Keywords : policy implementation fourth generation of public policy bibliometric analysis governance networks collaborative governance