School‑Based Governance and Self‑Management: A Comparative Review of Models in Australia, Canada, and England and Their Adaptability to Developing Countries

School‑Based Governance and Self‑Management: A Comparative Review of Models in Australia, Canada, and England and Their Adaptability to Developing Countries

Amir hossein Hassani Alikelayeh1

1) M.A. Student in Educational Governance, iran, Comprehensive University of the Islamic Revolution -

IOI Code : AAHC-ABECZF
Publication : National Conference on Management, Commercialization, Knowledge-Based Economy and Investment for Production(impeb.ir)
Abstract :
    The purpose of this study is to conduct a comparative review of school-based governance models in Australia, Canada, and England, and to examine their applicability to developing countries, with a particular focus on Iran. School-based governance—defined as the delegation of decision-making authority from central agencies to schools—has advanced considerably in developed countries, yet faces structural, political, and capacity-related challenges in developing contexts. This research employs a qualitative–comparative approach using Brady’s four-stage model (description, interpretation, juxtaposition, and comparison), drawing on analyses of official policy documents, organizational reports, and peer‑reviewed scholarly literature. The findings indicate that while all three countries emphasize shared principles such as the separation of governance from executive management, three core responsibilities (vision setting, accountability, and financial oversight), and transparency, each model also exhibits distinctive features: Australia’s “five pillars of good governance” and its rule of absolute majority; Canada’s multi‑year strategic planning and regular self‑assessment; and England’s multi‑tiered structure of Multi‑Academy Trusts. In contrast, developing countries grapple with challenges such as the gap between law and practice, political interference, limited capacity and skills, and the absence of a culture of horizontal accountability. For Iran, the study proposes redesigning the model of trustee schools, establishing school councils with deliberative‑advisory and decision‑making functions, mandating the development of school improvement plans, and providing specialized training programs for council members.

Keywords : school based governance self management comparative study developing countries