From Physical Asset Management to Asset Governance under Outsourced Operations: A Critical Analysis

From Physical Asset Management to Asset Governance under Outsourced Operations: A Critical Analysis

Mohammad Pourmoghaddam1

1) PhD in Public Administration, Organizational Behavior, Islamic Azad University of Central Tehran, Tehran, Iran

IOI Code : AAHC-ABZKDH
Publication : National Conference on Management, Commercialization, Knowledge-Based Economy and Investment for Production(impeb.ir)
Abstract :
    In recent years, Physical Asset Management (PAM) has been promoted as a universal and prescriptive solution for all employers and owners of infrastructure assets. Full implementation of this approach typically requires substantial investment in digital systems, organizational structures, and operational capabilities. Adopting a critical, analytical, and policy-oriented perspective, this paper challenges this dominant assumption and argues that comprehensive and costly implementation of PAM is not only unnecessary for all asset owners but can also be inefficient—and even misleading—in organizational contexts characterized by outsourced operations. This study is grounded in the key premise that when physical assets are placed under the control or lease of operators, and when all operational and maintenance costs are borne by these operators, the role of the asset owner or employer should be redefined from executive asset management to asset governance. The findings indicate that an owner’s emphasis on implementing operational asset management systems—such as Computerized Maintenance Management Systems (CMMS) or Enterprise Asset Management (EAM) platforms—without possessing real executive authority leads to the production of large volumes of data that have little direct influence on operational decisions, while merely increasing institutional and administrative costs. In contrast, greater attention to policy formulation, strategic orientation, performance requirements, the design of key performance indicators, institutional oversight, and capital investment decision-making at the ownership level proves far more effective in safeguarding asset value and managing ownership-related risks. By proposing a three-level conceptual model comprising a strategic level (owner or employer), a tactical level (shared oversight and regulation), and an operational level (operator or contractor), the paper demonstrates that PAM should be viewed as a supporting instrument for asset governance, rather than as an all-encompassing executive system at the owner’s organizational level. Rejecting the “one-size-fits-all” approach, this study offers clear implications for policymakers, regulatory bodies, and infrastructure owners in designing more cost-effective, efficient, and realistic models of asset management.

Keywords : asset governance physical asset management outsourced operations owner operator separation