Jurisdictional Conflicts between the Peace Court and Other Authorities
Jurisdictional Conflicts between the Peace Court and Other Authorities
Ali Qarehbaghi1 Ali Abdi2
1) ¹ Assistant Professor, Department of Private Law, Bonab Branch, Islamic Azad University, Bonab, Iran.
2) ² Master’s Degree in Private Law, Maragheh Branch, Islamic Azad University, Maragheh, Iran.
IOI Code
:
AAHC-ACZCBC
Publication :
National Conference on Management, Commercialization, Knowledge-Based Economy and Investment for Production(impeb.ir)
Abstract :
The 2023 Law on Dispute Resolution Councils and the establishment of the Peace Court have introduced a new framework for allocating jurisdiction among different authorities, with the objectives of specializing judicial proceedings, reducing delays in litigation, and separating judicial functions from conciliation and settlement functions. Nevertheless, potential overlaps of jurisdiction between Peace Courts and general and criminal courts, family courts, public prosecutors’ offices, Dispute Resolution Councils, and non-judicial authorities may increase the likelihood of confusion among litigants and undermine legal certainty. Accordingly, the precise delineation of the Peace Court’s jurisdiction and the establishment of an effective mechanism for resolving jurisdictional conflicts constitute essential necessities. This study aims to examine the foundations, instances, and consequences of jurisdictional conflicts between the Peace Court and other authorities, as well as to assess the legal approaches governing the determination of the competent authority. The research adopts a descriptive-analytical method and relies on library-based research, analysis of statutory provisions, advisory opinions, and legal viewpoints. The findings indicate that the new law, while transferring a significant portion of the former judicial jurisdiction of Dispute Resolution Councils to Peace Courts, has created a form of relative jurisdiction for this authority. In resolving jurisdictional conflicts, the law has also emphasized the role of provincial courts of appeal in various circumstances. However, ambiguity persists regarding certain jurisdictional categories, the manner of dealing with related and incidental claims, the relationship between administrative referral and orders declaring lack of jurisdiction, the scope of Peace Court jurisdiction vis-à-vis non-judicial authorities, the status of claims concerning eviction and rights arising from lease relationships, the procedure for referring matters to Dispute Resolution Councils, and the effects of jurisdiction-related decisions. Such ambiguities may continue to give rise to inconsistent judicial practice and delays in proceedings. The findings demonstrate that the success of the new system depends primarily on the harmonized interpretation of legal provisions, the precise determination of jurisdictional boundaries among authorities, the strengthening of the role of courts of appeal in developing a consistent judicial practice, and the legislative clarification of existing ambiguities. In this manner, Peace Courts may adjudicate the prescribed claims promptly and professionally, prevent jurisdictional overlap with other authorities, reduce the workload of general courts, minimize the repeated transfer of cases, and ultimately enhance the efficiency of the judicial system.
Keywords : peace court jurisdictional conflict relative jurisdiction dispute resolution council