Identifying Drivers and Mapping Scenarios for the Development of Judicial Decision-Support AI by the Year 1415 (An Evidence-Based Futures Study Focusing on Iran s Judicial System)
Identifying Drivers and Mapping Scenarios for the Development of Judicial Decision-Support AI by the Year 1415 (An Evidence-Based Futures Study Focusing on Iran s Judicial System)
setareh jalali1
1) PhD Student in Cultural Sociology, Islamic Azad University, Dehaghan Branch
IOI Code
:
AAHD-ABKKZE
Publication :
National Conference on Information Technology, Nanotechnology, Artificial Intelligence and Technological Futures Studies(itnaf.ir)
Abstract :
The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into the judicial system, particularly beyond the level of administrative automation, is gradually transforming the way judicial activities are conducted and supported. Today, some intelligent systems can assist judges in retrieving legal resources and knowledge, analyzing documents, summarizing case files, identifying legal issues, and even providing recommendations relevant to judicial decision-making. Alongside these significant opportunities, however, this transformation raises important questions concerning technology, law, judicial organization, judicial independence, and professional responsibility.
The present study was conducted with the aim of identifying the key drivers influencing the development of AI-based judicial decision-support systems and mapping alternative futures toward the horizon of 1415 in the Iranian calendar (2036). In terms of orientation, the study is applied, while in terms of purpose, it is exploratory and futures-oriented. To achieve its objectives, the study employed secondary evidence analysis, a targeted literature review, document analysis, and monitoring of emerging developments. The main corpus consisted of 26 selected sources organized into four categories: “Iranian documents and evidence,” “international governance frameworks,” “scientific and empirical studies in the judicial domain,” and “socio-technical and futures studies.”
The results of the content coding led to the identification of 15 influential factors. The strongest body of evidence concerned issues such as the sensitivity and scope of AI applications, the need for meaningful human oversight and the preservation of judicial independence, the integration of technology into judicial organizations, regulation and accountability, pressures arising from the need for greater efficiency, as well as legitimacy and fairness. Analysis of the role of these factors further indicated that data governance and quality, the technical reliability of AI systems, infrastructure, organizational integration, regulation and accountability, human oversight, judicial competencies, continuous evaluation, and pressures arising from caseloads are among the most important forces shaping the development trajectory of AI-based judicial decision-support systems.
An assessment of the Iranian context indicates that the issue is no longer confined to policy formulation and planning and has entered an initial stage of implementation. The existence of more than 100 million anonymized judicial decisions, more than 900 judicial web services, over one billion information transactions over a five-year period, and reports of more than 1,000 daily queries submitted to the intelligent judicial assistant provide indications of this transition. Nevertheless, independent and publicly available information on error rates, algorithmic bias, the legal quality of system outputs, and the actual impact of these systems on the quality of judicial decisions remains limited.
Based on the findings, two strategic uncertainties—“technical-data maturity and system reliability” and “legal-human governance maturity”—were selected as the two principal axes of the scenario framework. Combining these two uncertainties produced four alternative scenarios: “the empowered and accountable judge,” “unrestrained algorithmic acceleration,” “institutional caution,” and “fragmented and fragile digitalization.” The findings indicate that the desirable future of judicial decision support cannot be achieved merely by increasing algorithmic capabilities; rather, it requires the simultaneous development of trustworthy technology, high-quality data, meaningful human oversight and control, and transparent accountability mechanisms.
Keywords : artificial intelligence judicial decision support iran s judicial system