Intuition vs. Systematization: Analysis of Behavioral and Operational Challenges for Auditors Facing Management’s Motivational Risks
Intuition vs. Systematization: Analysis of Behavioral and Operational Challenges for Auditors Facing Management’s Motivational Risks
Mohammad Taghi Kabiri1 Keramat Allah Heydari Rostami2 Mohadese Yousefi Zadeh3
1) Assistant Professor, Department of Accounting, Faculty of Administrative Sciences and Economics, Arak University, Arak, Iran. Email:
2) Assistant Professor, Department of Accounting, Faculty of Administrative Sciences and Economics, Arak University, Arak, Iran. Email:
3) M.Sc. Student in Accounting, Faculty of Administrative Affairs and Economics, Arak University, Arak, Iran. Email:
IOI Code
:
AAHD-ABKZKZ
Publication :
National Conference on Information Technology, Nanotechnology, Artificial Intelligence and Technological Futures Studies(itnaf.ir)
Abstract :
In the last decade, the global financial reporting system has faced an unprecedented credibility crisis rooted in the exponential growth of financial statement fraud. Direct losses from fraud have exceeded manageable thresholds, constituting a systemic threat to capital market stability. At the heart of this crisis, independent auditors face growing criticism. Theoretical and empirical literature firmly establishes that management incentive packages are among the most powerful fraud drivers. The inherent conflict of interest between managers and shareholders, exacerbated by short-term performance-based pay structures, creates strong motives for intentional accounting manipulation. Multiple pieces of evidence show that high levels of cash or equity-based compensation significantly increase the likelihood of financial fraud. Despite this strong theoretical consensus, a deep gap exists between theoretical knowledge and practical application in audit risk assessment. The traditional risk assessment model lacks a systematic mechanism to integrate management incentive analysis as an independent source of fraud risk. Findings indicate that auditors, in practice, review incentive documents on an ad hoc, irregular basis dependent on individual judgment, rarely reflecting this in formal risk documentation. This regulatory silence places auditors in a precarious position; aware of the risk but lacking formal tools to convert this awareness into a targeted, defensible method. Furthermore, the technological landscape exacerbates this complexity. Advances in AI and data analytics offer powerful tools for detecting hidden fraud patterns, but traditional auditors often lack sufficient knowledge to use them effectively. This technological gap widens the motivational gap, providing opportunities for financial criminals to use similar tools for more sophisticated concealment. This qualitative study explores auditors’ intuition and lived experience regarding management incentives, aiming to extract operational challenges and propose solutions to improve the current situation.
Keywords : fraud risk auditor intuition incentive packages auditing standards operational challenges