Rethinking Skill and Judgment in Art Education with Machine Learning from the Perspective of Dewey’s Aesthetic Experience

Rethinking Skill and Judgment in Art Education with Machine Learning from the Perspective of Dewey’s Aesthetic Experience

Zeynab Arab Mistani1

1) PhD Graduate, Department of Philosophy, Sanandaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Sanandaj, Iran –

IOI Code : AAHD-ACZAAH
Publication : National Conference on Information Technology, Nanotechnology, Artificial Intelligence and Technological Futures Studies(itnaf.ir)
Abstract :
    The integration of machine learning into art education has posed a fundamental conceptual challenge to the traditional understanding of artistic skill and aesthetic judgment. Generative systems, by redefining the boundaries between the human agent and technological mediation, transform the transactional structure of experience and destabilize the longstanding connection among action, perception, and qualitative fulfillment. Despite the growing literature addressing the technological and pedagogical dimensions of this transformation, its philosophical examination from the perspective of John Dewey’s theory of aesthetic experience remains limited. The central theoretical gap lies in the absence of a profound conceptual reconsideration of the categories of skill and judgment based on the rhythmic and transactional structure of action-perception, intelligent habit, and the possibility of consummation. This study aims to conceptually rethink skill and judgment in human-machine relations through the lens of Dewey’s aesthetic experience. The research proceeds through conceptual analysis and hermeneutic interpretation, employing Dewey’s central categories—perception, rhythm, consummation, and judgment—as analytical lenses through which to examine the structure of machine-learning-mediated artistic experience. The conceptual argument demonstrates that skill is reconfigured from fixed technical mastery into an intelligent and relational habit, one that manifests itself in the qualitative guidance of interaction with a generative and indeterminate system. Judgment likewise evolves from an external verdict into a critical and experiential qualitative discernment that determines the direction of experience within the continuum of action and perception. Aesthetic experience itself, in this relation, remains continually exposed to a structural tension between preserving rhythm and continuity on the one hand and the risk of disruption and reduction on the other; a tension that determines the possibility of enriching experience or its descent into insensibility. The theoretical conclusion of the study is that Deweyan aesthetics provides a powerful framework for reformulating skill and judgment in the age of machine learning. This rethinking understands the machine as an active mediator in shaping the transactional structure of experience and compels the philosophy of art education to reconstruct its aims and criteria around the continuity of experience, the cultivation of intelligent habit, and the possibility of consummation. In this way, technological affordances can be utilized without sacrificing the aesthetic core of experience.

Keywords : machine learning art education dewey’s aesthetic experience skill judgment human machine co creation