Identification and Prioritization of Contractor Selection Criteria in Construction Projects Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)

Identification and Prioritization of Contractor Selection Criteria in Construction Projects Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)

Mohammad Hossein Izadi1 Ardalan Feili2

1) M.Sc. Student in Construction Management, Apadana Institute of Higher Education, Shiraz, Iran
2) Assistant Professor, Apadana Institute of Higher Education, Shiraz, Iran

IOI Code : AAHE-ACZZCE
Publication : National Conference on Civil Engineering, Design and Construction Technologies, Energy, Materials and Advanced Machinery(icaeu.ir)
Abstract :
    Contractor selection in construction projects is a strategic decision that directly influences project time, cost, and quality. Exclusive reliance on the lowest bid price may result in selecting a contractor with inadequate capacity, leading to delays, cost overruns, and quality deterioration. This study aimed to identify and prioritize the criteria affecting contractor selection in construction projects. The criteria were identified through a review of previous studies and consultations with experts. To reduce the number and complexity of pairwise comparisons, seven criteria were organized into three clusters: resume and technical background, capability and execution capacity, and bid price. The relative importance of the criteria was determined using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) based on the judgments of six construction management experts. The experts judgments, representing a cumulative total of 150 years of relevant professional experience, were aggregated using the weighted geometric mean method. The maximum inconsistency ratio of the experts pairwise comparisons was 0.082, which is below the acceptable threshold of 0.10, indicating acceptable consistency of the judgments. The results showed that past performance and client satisfaction is the most important criterion for contractor selection, followed by price reasonableness in second place. In contrast, low bid price alone ranked sixth and was found to be considerably less important than price reasonableness. The resulting model can assist employers in transitioning from a price-driven selection approach to a balanced evaluation of technical competence, execution capability, past performance, and bid price reasonableness.

Keywords : contractor selection construction management analytic hierarchy process (ahp) multi criteria decision making bid price