Sophistry and Fallacy: From Formal Logic to Deconstruction of Language A Philosophical-Logical Examination of the Boundaries of Rationality and Power in Discourse

Sophistry and Fallacy: From Formal Logic to Deconstruction of Language A Philosophical-Logical Examination of the Boundaries of Rationality and Power in Discourse

Ali Rakhshani1

1) M.A. Candidate in Architecture, Hakim Sabzevari University, Sabzevar, Iran;

IOI Code : AAHF-ABFCAG
Publication : National Conference on Architecture and Art Technologies, Smart City, Soft and Creative Industries and Technological Culture(icact.ir)
Abstract :
    This paper provides an in-depth examination of the concepts of sophistry and fallacy from the perspectives of formal logic, the history of philosophy, and the theory of linguistic deconstruction. While traditional logic defines these notions merely as deviations from valid reasoning, a deconstructive approach interprets them as signs of resistance against the dominance of formal logic. Through a historical analysis of ancient Greek sophists, a review of logical definitions, and behavioral examples of the transformation of human rationality in times of crisis, the study demonstrates that the boundary between logic and fallacy is fluid and contingent upon power. In its final section, drawing on Jacques Derrida s theory of deconstruction, this paper argues that sophistry and fallacy are not only logical errors but also languages of resistance against imposed certainties. This perspective holds particular significance for architects and designers, as design itself constitutes a space where formal logic interacts with lived experience, ambiguity, and difference. Ultimately, the paper concludes that for an architectural critique of a building, one must understand logic within illogic; that is, to know when our critique is based on structural and functional logic, and when it is based on lived experience, aesthetics, and meaning—which may conflict with formal logic yet still possess their own distinct logic.

Keywords : sophistry logical fallacy formal logic deconstruction logic within illogic