Analyzing the Factors Influencing Building Code Violations and Their Relative Rates Across Urban Districts: A Case Study of Article 100 Commission Case Files, Qazvin Municipality

Analyzing the Factors Influencing Building Code Violations and Their Relative Rates Across Urban Districts: A Case Study of Article 100 Commission Case Files, Qazvin Municipality

Amir Nasiri1 Ehsan Bagheri Aghababa2 Kaveh Taherkhani3

1) Expert, Supervision Department, Deputy of Urban Planning and Architecture, Qazvin Municipality
2) Head of the Building Violations Department, Qazvin Municipality
3) Detailed Plan Coordinator, District 4 Municipality, Qazvin Municipality

IOI Code : AAHF-ABHGDH
Publication : National Conference on Architecture and Art Technologies, Smart City, Soft and Creative Industries and Technological Culture(icact.ir)
Abstract :
    Building code violations constitute one of the most significant challenges to urban management in Iran, creating not only inconsistencies in the physical development of cities but also generating substantial economic, social, and environmental consequences. This study aims to analyze the status of building violations and examine the patterns underlying cases reviewed by the Article 100 Commission of Qazvin Municipality. The research is applied in purpose and descriptive–analytical in nature. The required data were extracted from Article 100 Commission case files across the four municipal districts of Qazvin for the period 2023–2025 (Iranian calendar years 1402–1404). The data were analyzed using descriptive statistical methods and comparative analyses, including normalization of violation data relative to the number of building permits issued. The findings indicate that, during the study period, a total of 6,049 cases involving 52,003 building violations were recorded in Qazvin. Based on the absolute number of cases and violations, District 4 accounted for the largest share. However, normalization of violations by the number of building permits issued revealed that District 2 had the highest actual violation rate in the city, with 25.5 violations per building permit—approximately 39% higher than District 4. This finding suggests that the large number of violations recorded in District 4 primarily reflects its higher volume of construction activity rather than a higher propensity for violations. The relatively high land values in District 2 were identified as one of the likely factors contributing to its elevated violation rate. Among the different categories of violations, unauthorized additional floor area, unauthorized change of land use, and parking deficiency were the most prevalent. Furthermore, monetary fines constituted the most frequent type of decision issued by the Article 100 Commission. The observed decline in the ratio of Article 100 cases to building permits during the study period—from 243 to 197 cases per 100 building permits—coincided with strengthened cooperation between Qazvin Municipality and the Engineering Organization in supervising the performance of supervising engineers, as well as the automation of reporting and enforcement procedures for building violations. Accordingly, revising the penalty framework under Article 100, reallocating inspection priorities based on the relative rate of violations rather than their absolute number (with particular emphasis on District 2), expanding intelligent monitoring systems, and sustaining inter-institutional collaboration can play a significant role in reducing building violations and improving urban governance.

Keywords : building violations article 100 commission urban management urban governance