Diagnosing the Unintended Consequences of Physical Interventions in Intermediate Cities of Iran: A Critical Analysis of Urban Projects in Zanjan (1981–2021)
Diagnosing the Unintended Consequences of Physical Interventions in Intermediate Cities of Iran: A Critical Analysis of Urban Projects in Zanjan (1981–2021)
Akbar Norouzi1
1) Department of Urban Planning, Qazvin Branch, Islamic Azad University, Qazvin, Iran
IOI Code
:
AAHF-ABHKFH
Publication :
National Conference on Architecture and Art Technologies, Smart City, Soft and Creative Industries and Technological Culture(icact.ir)
Abstract :
Abstract
Introduction and Research Significance: Physical interventions in cities have always been accompanied by the illusion that stated objectives will inevitably translate into actual outcomes. However, four decades of urban planning experience in Iran demonstrates that many urban projects, alongside their expected achievements, have produced unintended consequences that were overlooked during the decision-making process. These unintended consequences, which in the impact assessment literature are categorized under concepts such as environmental, social, and visual impact assessment, are often discovered belatedly due to the lack of structured frameworks and one-dimensional approaches in urban planning.
Research Objective: The present study aims to diagnose the unintended consequences of physical interventions in Iran s intermediate cities. The research employs a descriptive-analytical method, relying on field observation, documentary review, and qualitative content analysis.
Scope of the Study: The scope encompasses nine flagship urban projects in the city of Zanjan between 1981 and 2021, selected as representative samples of physical interventions over the past four decades.
Research Findings: The findings indicate that the unintended consequences of these interventions can be classified into four dimensions: environmental (such as the obstruction of underground water corridors), social (such as inducing a sense of spatial discrimination), traffic-related (including induced traffic generated by multi-story parking structures), and visual (such as landscape proliferation and residual spaces).
Discussion and Conclusion: The conclusion of the study confirms that transitioning from a project-oriented approach to a consequence-oriented approach necessitates the development of comprehensive pre-implementation assessment annexes and a fundamental revision of the urban management decision-making system.
Keywords : unintended consequences physical interventions impact assessment intermediate cities urban pathology zanjan