Prioritizing safety risks in urban excavation using Piprecia and Cocoso methods

Prioritizing safety risks in urban excavation using Piprecia and Cocoso methods

mohammad kheradranjbar1 mohammad eskandari2 mehrdad najddad3 hamidreza marzani4

1) Department of Civil Engineering, Karaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Karaj, Iran; and Housing and Building Research Center, Karaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Karaj, Iran
2) Department of Civil Engineering, Karaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Karaj, Iran; and Housing and Building Research Center, Karaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Karaj, Iran
3) M.Sc. Student, Department of Civil Engineering, Karaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Karaj, Iran
4) M.Sc. Student, Department of Civil Engineering, Karaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Karaj, Iran

IOI Code : AAHF-ABKBEF
Publication : National Conference on Architecture and Art Technologies, Smart City, Soft and Creative Industries and Technological Culture(icact.ir)
Abstract :
    Excavation operations in urban areas are considered high-risk activities in construction projects due to complex geotechnical conditions, limited working space, proximity to existing buildings and underground utilities, and the potential for execution and management errors. Therefore, given the constraints on financial, temporal, and operational resources, prioritizing areas for control interventions is essential for the effective management of safety risks associated with excavation. This study employed a hybrid multi-criteria decision-making approach to prioritize control measures related to safety risks in urban excavation operations. In the first stage, four criteria were identified—namely, the impact of risk control on safety enhancement, economic savings from loss prevention, time savings from reduced downtime and delays, and the impact of risk control on maintaining project quality—and were weighted using the PIPRECIA method based on expert opinion. The results indicated that the criterion regarding the impact of risk control on safety enhancement holds the greatest importance, with a final weight of 0.3168, followed by the criteria of economic savings (0.2425), quality preservation (0.2374), and time savings (0.2034). This finding indicates that when selecting control measures, their ability to prevent accidents and mitigate safety consequences serves as the primary basis for decision-making, although economic, quality, and time-related considerations also play a significant role in determining priorities. In the second stage, decision options—encompassing control and management measures for the identified safety risks—were prioritized using the CoCoSo method. The results indicate that controlling the lateral displacement and deformation of the excavation wall holds the highest priority for intervention, with a score of 85.607. Additionally, the control of non-compliance with safety protocols and inadequate safety oversight (scoring 84.733) and the control of damage to underground facilities and urban infrastructure (scoring 83.514) ranked second and third, respectively. Accordingly, focusing on the continuous monitoring of excavation wall deformations, controlling the execution of retaining structures, enhancing safety inspections and oversight, and protecting underground utilities and adjacent buildings can improve the effectiveness of safety risk management in excavation projects. The framework proposed in this study can serve as a tool for the targeted allocation of resources, the prioritization of control measures, and decision-making support for managers of urban excavation projects.

Keywords : urban excavation safety risk multi criteria decision making piprecia method cocoso method