A Comparative Study of the Representation of Women’s Lived Experience in the Works of Grandma Moses and Mokarrameh Ghanbari

A Comparative Study of the Representation of Women’s Lived Experience in the Works of Grandma Moses and Mokarrameh Ghanbari

Fatemeh Ashrafi1

1) M.A. Student of Painting, Faculty of Art, Shahed University, Tehran, Iran

IOI Code : AAHF-ABKHAG
Publication : National Conference on Architecture and Art Technologies, Smart City, Soft and Creative Industries and Technological Culture(icact.ir)
Abstract :
    Women’s lived experience is an important concept in contemporary art studies, and its manifestation in the works of self-taught artists offers valuable insight into the diverse dimensions of women’s lives, identities, social roles, and inner worlds across different cultural contexts. This study comparatively examines the representation of women’s lived experience in the works of Grandma Moses and Mokarrameh Ghanbari, two self-taught artists from distinct cultural contexts. It asks how women’s lived experience is represented in the works of these two artists and what similarities and differences can be identified in their themes, visual elements, and modes of expression. Employing a descriptive-analytical method and a comparative approach, the study draws on library research and the analysis of selected works by the two artists. The findings indicate that, despite differences in their cultural, geographical, historical, and social backgrounds, both artists represent everyday life, family, work, nature, memory, and women’s social roles as central dimensions of their lived experience, primarily through narrative imagery. A direct and accessible visual language, formal simplicity, vivid colors, and an emphasis on personal memory constitute some of the major similarities between their works. At the same time, differences in their cultural contexts and lifeworlds have resulted in distinct themes, symbols, compositional strategies, and modes of visual narration. Grandma Moses places greater emphasis on collective memory and the rural and traditional way of life of premodern America, whereas Mokarrameh Ghanbari foregrounds personal experience, individual emotions, family relationships, and elements of Iranian vernacular culture. Overall, the study demonstrates that self-taught art, beyond geographical and cultural boundaries, can provide a significant medium for representing women’s lived experience and articulating their individual and cultural identities.

Keywords : women’s lived experience self taught art representation mokarrameh ghanbari grandma moses