Religious Law, Formal Rationality, and Economic Action: A Re-reading of Max Weber’s Analysis of the Pharisees
Religious Law, Formal Rationality, and Economic Action: A Re-reading of Max Weber’s Analysis of the Pharisees
seyed jalalaldin hosseini1
1) Trainer at the Technical and Vocational Training Organization of Iran
IOI Code
:
ABDE-ABCGAZ
Publication :
6th International Conference on Advanced Research in Management And Humanities(huconf.com)
Abstract :
The relationship between religion and economy in social theory has often been interpreted either through economic reductionism or primarily through the lens of Protestantism and modern capitalism. Yet Max Weber’s analysis of ancient Judaism—particularly the Pharisees—has received comparatively limited conceptual attention within the broader framework of his theory of rationalization. Focusing on Das antike Judentum, this article argues that, in Weber’s account, Pharisaic religious law represents not merely a system of belief but a form of formal rationality. Through rule-bound discipline, generalization of norms, and the primacy of impersonal law over personal authority, this legal-religious order generates a predictable and structured pattern of social action. Such a configuration exhibits a structural affinity with the requirements of rational economic action. By clarifying the distinction between formal and substantive rationality and emphasizing Weber’s concept of elective affinity, the article demonstrates that the relationship between religion and economic life in Weber’s thought is neither linear nor causally deterministic, but historically and structurally mediated. Reinterpreting the Pharisees as an instance of religious rationalization thus contributes to a renewed understanding of the possible connections between religious law and economic rationality.
Keywords : max weber formal rationality religious law economic action sociology of religion elective affinity