The Theoretical Gap in Managing Toxic Organizations in Educational Management: Explaining the Need to Develop a Theory for Schools
The Theoretical Gap in Managing Toxic Organizations in Educational Management: Explaining the Need to Develop a Theory for Schools
Adel Zahed Babolan1 Fatemeh Bagheri2 Husein Tagavi3 Ali KhaleghKhah4
1) Professor, Department of Educational Sciences, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, University of Mohaghegh Ardabili, Ardabil, Iran
2) Corresponding Author: Ph.D candidate of Educational Management, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, University of Mohaghegh Ardabili, Ardabil, Iran.
3) Associate Professor, Department of Educational Sciences, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, University of Mohaghegh Ardabili, Ardabil, Iran.
4) Professor, Department of Educational Sciences, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, University of Mohaghegh Ardabili, Ardabil, Iran.
IOI Code
:
ABDE-ABKEED
Publication :
6th International Conference on Advanced Research in Management And Humanities(huconf.com)
Abstract :
This study aims to explain the theoretical gap in managing toxic organizations within educational management systems and to propose an alternative framework for understanding, preventing, and containing organizational toxicity in schools. The central problem addressed in this research is that much of the existing literature has predominantly explained organizational toxicity through individual-centered, behavior-centered, or culture-centered perspectives, thereby overlooking its structural, governance-based, and inter-level roots. In schools, organizational toxicity is not merely the result of a toxic principal, interpersonal conflicts, or a negative school climate; rather, it may emerge from an imbalanced governance architecture characterized by excessive centralization, ambiguity in the distribution of authority and responsibility, weak accountability, disrupted information flows, and the erosion of justice, trust, and psychological safety. The study employed a qualitative, theory-building, and conceptual-analytical research design. Drawing on social systems theory and multilevel governance, the relevant literature on organizational toxicity, toxic organizations, and educational governance was critically reviewed and synthesized to develop the “Multilevel Governance for Managing Toxic Organizations in Schools” framework.” Within this framework, multilevel governance capacity functions as a regulatory and intervening mechanism that plays a central role in constraining self-reinforcing cycles of toxicity. These cycles often begin with distrust and are reproduced through excessive control, organizational silence, perceived injustice, job burnout, and reduced professional participation. The theoretical contribution of the study indicates that role clarity, alignment between authority and responsibility, inter-level coordination, safe reporting mechanisms, learning-oriented accountability, and specialized support from meso-level actors can mitigate the effects of structural risk factors. The main innovation of this research lies in shifting the analytical focus from the “toxic individual” to “governance architecture” and in moving from reactive and punitive interventions toward preventive, structural, and learning-oriented approaches. Accordingly, the sustainable management of organizational toxicity in schools requires redesigning the relationships among macro, meso, and school-level governance actors rather than merely replacing individuals.
Keywords : theory building toxic organizations multilevel governance educational management governance architecture