Examining the impact of prior theories, judicial statements, and litigants orientation on the mental independence of the official judicial expert
Examining the impact of prior theories, judicial statements, and litigants orientation on the mental independence of the official judicial expert
Hossein Yousefi1
1) Official expert of justice
IOI Code
:
ABEB-ABFCEZ
Publication :
4th International Conference on Recent Advances in Engineering, Innovation and Technology - Belgium(eitconf.com)
Abstract :
The impartiality and mental independence of judicial experts constitute one of the fundamental pillars of the credibility of expert opinions in judicial proceedings. Nevertheless, expert decision-making, like other human cognitive processes, is constantly exposed to various forms of cognitive bias. Among these biases, anchoring bias is considered one of the most influential, emerging from initial exposure to directional information and subsequently affecting later evaluations and judgments.
In judicial expertise processes, factors such as prior expert opinions, the wording of judicial referral orders, judges’ remarks, lawyers’ suggestions, litigants’ narratives, and even media coverage surrounding a case may unconsciously influence the expert’s mindset and undermine the independence of professional assessment.
Using a descriptive-analytical methodology and drawing upon legal literature, cognitive psychology studies, and comparative legal research, this article examines different dimensions of anchoring bias in judicial expertise. The findings indicate that a considerable portion of conflicts among expert opinions, objections to expert reports, and inconsistencies in forensic evaluations arise not merely from technical disagreements but also from cognitive biases and the influence of pre-existing information on expert decision-making.
Furthermore, comparative analysis demonstrates that several legal systems have attempted to mitigate such biases through mechanisms including blind assessment procedures, restriction of unnecessary background information, and specialized training on cognitive biases.
Finally, the article proposes several practical solutions aimed at enhancing the impartiality and reliability of expert opinions, including the principle of minimum necessary information, professional education on cognitive biases, reform of judicial referral procedures, and implementation of independent assessment models.
Keywords : judicial expertise anchoring bias expert witness judicial proceedings impartiality decision making