Development of a Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Model for the Optimal Selection of Sustainable Materials in the Reconstruction of Urban Sidewalks (Case Study: Streets of Karaj)
Development of a Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Model for the Optimal Selection of Sustainable Materials in the Reconstruction of Urban Sidewalks (Case Study: Streets of Karaj)
Salman Abbasi Sahebi1 Saeed Jamalpour Najmabad2
1) Master’s Student, Civil Engineering (Construction Management), Islamic Azad University, Karaj Branch, Iran,
2) Assistant Professor, Adjunct Faculty Member, Department of Civil Engineering, Islamic Azad University, Karaj Branch, Iran,
IOI Code
:
ABEB-ACAFZE
Publication :
4th International Conference on Recent Advances in Engineering, Innovation and Technology - Belgium(eitconf.com)
Abstract :
Pavement construction is a key element of urban spaces; the quality of the materials used directly impacts safety, durability, citizen comfort, life-cycle costs, and the sustainability of the urban environment. This study aims to identify and prioritize the factors influencing the selection of innovative materials—as opposed to traditional ones—for pavement construction, with a specific focus on the physical and climatic conditions of streets in the city of Karaj. The research is applied in nature, employs a descriptive-analytical methodology, and utilizes a multi-criteria decision-making approach. The statistical population consisted of 66 experts and specialists in the fields of urban planning, civil engineering, architecture, and urban management in Karaj. Data were collected via a pairwise comparison questionnaire. Following the validation of the instrument (confirming its validity and reliability), the weights of the criteria and the prioritization of the alternatives were calculated using the Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process (FAHP), based on Chang’s extent analysis approach. The weighting results indicated that technical and functional criteria ranked first (with a weight of 0.298), followed by economic (0.242), environmental (0.186), maintenance and operation (0.136), executive and managerial (0.094), and social and aesthetic (0.044) criteria. In the evaluation of alternatives, porous/permeable concrete (Innovative Material 1) ranked first (with a weight of 0.274), while modern polymeric/nano and composite paving materials (Innovative Material 2) ranked second (with a weight of 0.238). Meanwhile, traditional materials—such as conventional asphalt, pressed or vibrated concrete pavers, and natural stone—ranked lower, despite their advantages of lower initial costs and ease of procurement. Sensitivity analysis findings further demonstrated the stability and resilience of pervious concrete across most scenarios. Overall, the use of pervious concrete and polymer-based paving is considered an optimal choice for urban thoroughfares in Karaj, owing to their effectiveness in managing surface runoff, their resistance to abrasion, and their capacity to mitigate the urban heat island effect—provided that due attention is given to engineered sub-base construction, the training of installation crews, and life-cycle budgeting.
Keywords : modern materials traditional materials sidewalk construction multi criteria decision making pervious concrete sustainable urban development in karaj