Architecture After Response: Rethinking the Boundary Between Adaptation and Symbiosis
Architecture After Response: Rethinking the Boundary Between Adaptation and Symbiosis
Fatemeh Alizadeh1 Mohammadreza Heydari2
1) Department of Architecture, University of Tehran
2) Department of Architecture, Islamic Azad University, Qazvin Branch
IOI Code
:
ABEB-ACZKBC
Publication :
4th International Conference on Recent Advances in Engineering, Innovation and Technology - Belgium(eitconf.com)
Abstract :
In a substantial body of contemporary architectural research, attention has been directed toward building performance under environmental conditions, adaptation to climatic changes, resource-use optimization, and the enhancement of building transformability. Nevertheless, a building’s responsiveness to environmental factors and its capacity to maintain performance under changing conditions do not necessarily imply the establishment of a reciprocal and ecologically desirable relationship between the building and its surrounding environment. Accordingly, this study aims to clarify the conceptual distinction between architectural adaptation and environmental symbiosis and to identify criteria for assessing the validity of claims that architecture has progressed from adaptation to symbiosis. The research adopts a qualitative approach based on a conceptual and comparative analysis of scholarly literature on adaptive façade performance simulation, climate adaptation, ecological resilience, regenerative design, design for disassembly, and biodiversity assessment. The comparative analysis reveals that, despite their theoretical connections, these fields do not address identical subjects or research problems. Some focus on building performance and the capacity for change, others investigate the interaction between the built environment and living systems, while others concentrate on assessing ecological outcomes. To clarify these distinctions, five analytical criteria are formulated: relational scope, reciprocity of effects, temporal continuity, capacity for transformation, and ecological accountability. The principal contribution of this study is the conceptual articulation of this distinction and the development of a framework for the critical assessment of claims concerning environmental symbiosis. The framework, however, has yet to be empirically examined and validated. The findings indicate that adaptation and efficiency can contribute to improving the relationship between architecture and the environment; establishing symbiosis, however, requires evaluating the actual impacts of architectural projects within a defined spatial scale and over a specified period.
Keywords : symbiotic architecture architectural adaptation environmental responsiveness regenerative design ecological resilience building transformability