The position of private property and public interests in urban planning law and the criteria for the separation of property and land

The position of private property and public interests in urban planning law and the criteria for the separation of property and land

noruzali bahari sorkhe kav1

1) Tabriz Municipality

IOI Code : ABFG-ACZHBH
Publication : 12th.international Congress on Civil Engineering, Architecture, Art and Urban Development(12icsau.ir)
Abstract :
    In the modern Iranian legal system, the intersection of the right to private property as a fundamental right, the protection of which has been emphasized in numerous principles of the Constitution (including Article 47), with the public interest , which is considered a pillar of urban management and sustainable development, is one of the complex and recurring challenges in urban planning law. With the aim of carefully analyzing the nature of this conflict, this research has examined the criteria for the separation of lands and properties as interventionist tools of the municipality. The main issue is how urban management, in the process of preparing and implementing comprehensive and detailed plans, by applying physical, density restrictions and separation quotas, on the one hand seeks to provide per capita services, safety and urban order, and on the other hand, to what extent are these interventions consistent with the legitimate property rights of individuals and the rule of do no harm .This study, using a descriptive-analytical method and examining the documents of the relevant laws, including the Municipality Law (especially the amended Article 101), the Registration Law, the unanimous decisions of the Court of Administrative Justice, and the theories of legal doctrine, seeks to answer these questions: what are the grounds justifying the restriction of ownership and how can the violation of the acquired rights of owners be prevented in the process of separation? The findings of the research show that the Iranian legal system, under the influence of the theory of the social function of ownership , has given priority to public interests; so that today s separation of lands has become a complex, costly process, and is conditional on the transfer of part of the property to the municipality.However, analyses indicate that legal gaps in the precise determination of the damage resulting from these restrictions, ambiguity in the criteria, as well as broad interpretations of public interest by some authorities, have increased the gap between owners and urban management. The research ultimately concludes that establishing a sustainable and fair balance between individual rights and collective interests depends only on amending the laws with an emphasis on clarifying technical regulations, establishing a precise system of compensation for damages resulting from restrictions on property rights, and reviewing the executive procedures of urban development commissions to prevent the violation of individual rights under the guise of implementing urban development regulations

Keywords : private property public interests urban development rights land division separation of property detailed plans