Compatibility of International Legal Standards with the Macro-Level Governance System of Social Welfare and Health in the National Context

Compatibility of International Legal Standards with the Macro-Level Governance System of Social Welfare and Health in the National Context

Babak Azadegan1 Asadollah Mehrara2 Nastaran Talebi3

1) M.A. Student in Social Health and Welfare, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran Email:
2) Associate Professor, Department of Public Administration, Islamic Azad University, Qaemshahr, Iran -
3) M.A. Student in International Law, Payame Noor University, Tehran, Iran -

IOI Code : ABFK-ABKKGG
Publication : The third international conference on new researches in management, law, humanities and entrepreneurship(icmlhe.ir)
Abstract :
    This study examines the compatibility of international human rights norms ( particularly Article 12 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and its interpretation in General Comment No. 14) with Iran’s macro-level governance system of social welfare and health. Using documentary analysis and comparative thematic analysis, the study reviewed 27 official documents, including constitutional provisions, national health policies, and the Third to Sixth National Development Plans. The documents were analyzed through the four-dimensional AAAQ framework—availability, accessibility, acceptability, and quality—and the tripartite typology of state obligations: respect, protect, and fulfil, with the support of MAXQDA software. Inter-coder reliability was 0.86. The findings identified two overarching themes: “normative geometry” and “policy architecture.” At the legislative level, substantial convergence with international standards was evident, particularly regarding infrastructural availability and cultural acceptability. At the implementation level, however, the concentration of 89.13% of coded obligations on fulfilment, together with the limited emphasis on protection, indicated institutional imbalance. Moreover, out-of-pocket expenditure fluctuated between 38% and 54%, compared with the policy target of below 30%, while fragmented insurance funds continued to weaken financial protection. The study concludes that Iran’s health system demonstrates legislative but not yet fully functional compatibility with international law. Operational compatibility requires risk pooling, an effective referral system, accountable regulation, and sustainable health financing. Epilogue Statement: The right to health is not a market commodity subject to exchange; it is a vital common good and the ultimate test of the biological legitimacy of governance in safeguarding human dignity.

Keywords : international law right to health social welfare and social health public governance localization of international legal standards