Collective Security and Identity Crisis in NATO; A Legal-Political Analysis of the Expansion of the Alliance’s Extraterritorial Interventions in Countering International Terrorism in the Sahel Region
Collective Security and Identity Crisis in NATO; A Legal-Political Analysis of the Expansion of the Alliance’s Extraterritorial Interventions in Countering International Terrorism in the Sahel Region
Ali Gharib1
1) MA in International Relations, Department of Law and Political Science, Kharazmi University, Tehran, Iran
IOI Code
:
ABFK-ACZBKZ
Publication :
The third international conference on new researches in management, law, humanities and entrepreneurship(icmlhe.ir)
Abstract :
Security developments in the Sahel region between 2023 and 2026, along with the increasing concentration of activities of groups affiliated with Al-Qaeda and ISIS, the weakening of regional mechanisms, the withdrawal or reduction of the presence of some Western actors, and the increase in competition between foreign powers, have once again put the issue of the relationship between Euro-Atlantic security and extraterritorial instability on NATO’s agenda. During this same period, NATO has strengthened its political and institutional presence around the Sahel by approving the Southern Neighborhood Action Plan at the 2024 Washington Summit, updating the Counterterrorism Guidelines, deepening the “Defense and Security Capacity Building” package for Mauritania, and developing cooperation with the African Union. However, the term “NATO intervention in the Sahel” without distinguishing between coercive operations, military missions, operational support, and capacity building can create an incorrect legal picture, because until September 2026, NATO will not have independent and direct combat operations in the Sahel countries, and the dominant model is cooperation based on consent and partner request. The present study, using a descriptive-analytical method and combining normative legal analysis and documentary study, answers the question of to what extent the expansion of NATO’s extraterritorial role in countering terrorism in the Sahel is compatible with international law and the institutional identity of this coalition. The findings show that capacity building, training, information exchange, and support for African arrangements, provided that the host state has valid consent, respects human rights, and is coordinated with the UN and the African Union, are the least controversial paths from a legal perspective. In contrast, direct coercive action in the territory of a third state, except within the framework of Security Council authorization, valid consent, or strict conditions of individual or collective self-defense under Article 51 of the UN Charter, conflicts with the prohibition of the use of force and the principle of sovereignty. From a political perspective, turning the fight against terrorism into a license for “mission expansion” could exacerbate NATO’s identity crisis: an alliance that must balance collective defense in the Euro-Atlantic area, crisis management, and cooperative security risks reproducing interventionist and postcolonial perceptions if it becomes heavily involved in the Sahel. The article concludes that a “partnership-oriented, Africa-centric, rights-based” model for NATO is less costly, more legitimate, and more strategically sustainable than direct intervention.
Keywords : nato collective security collective defense identity crisis international terrorism sahel