Pathology of Organizational Culture Based on Coefficient of Variation, Importance–Performance Matrix, and Perceptual Gap Analysis of Organizational Levels (Case Study: Gol Gohar Iron and Steel Development Company)

Pathology of Organizational Culture Based on Coefficient of Variation, Importance–Performance Matrix, and Perceptual Gap Analysis of Organizational Levels (Case Study: Gol Gohar Iron and Steel Development Company)

Fatemeh Hesamfar1 Mahmoud Alavi Razavi2 Asghar Hadidi3

1) Human Resources Specialist , Human Resources Department of Golgohar iron & steel development company, Sirjan ,Kerman, Iran,
2) 1. Head of Human Resources, Human Resources Department, Golgohar Iron & Steel Development Company, Sirjan, Kerman, Iran,
3) Human Resources Manager, Human Resources Department, Golgohar Iron & Steel Development Company, Sirjan, Kerman,

IOI Code : ABFK-ACZFKA
Publication : The third international conference on new researches in management, law, humanities and entrepreneurship(icmlhe.ir)
Abstract :
    Organizational culture, as one of the most fundamental constructs in management and organizational behavior, has a profound impact on organizational performance, effectiveness, and survival. However, many industrial organizations in Iran, especially in heavy industries, lack a precise understanding of their cultural pathologies. This study aims to diagnose the organizational culture of Gol Gohar Iron and Steel Development Company. In terms of purpose, this research is applied, and methodologically, it is analytical–descriptive. The data used are secondary data obtained from a 38-item questionnaire covering 13 cultural components, administered in 1404 (2025) to 119 employees (out of a population of 261). The content validity of the instrument was confirmed using the Content Validity Ratio (CVR) (all items > 0.60), and its reliability was verified through Cronbach s alpha (0.91) and test–retest (0.85). Three complementary analytical approaches were employed: Importance–Performance Matrix (IPA) to identify critical components; Coefficient of Variation (CV) to measure consensus among viewpoints; and perceptual gap analysis to compare organizational levels. Findings showed that the overall mean organizational culture score was 3.41 out of 5. Three components— sustainable long-term relationships with an attachment approach (3.69), excellence-seeking and competitiveness (3.55), and value creation for customers (3.54)—were identified as relative strengths, while three components— clarity of duties and expectations (3.09), continuous learning and experiential learning (3.30), and team orientation (3.31)—were recognized as primary improvement priorities. The highest disagreement was related to results-oriented pragmatism with CV = 7.29%, and the lowest was related to excellence-seeking and competitiveness with CV = 2.54%. Perceptual gap analysis revealed a 9.33% gap between heads and experts/specialists in agreement with cultural components. Question 25 (risk-taking and acceptance of mistakes) with a score of 2.8 was identified as the most critical organizational culture pathology. The most significant managerial implication of this study is the necessity of serious attention to the three priority components in organizational transformation and development programs, and leveraging the identified strengths as levers to compensate for weaknesses. This study demonstrated that a combined and localized approach to organizational culture assessment can provide a more accurate and practical picture of organizational culture in specific industries.

Keywords : organizational culture organizational culture pathology coefficient of variation importance performance matrix perceptual gap steel industry gol gohar iron and steel development company